Join Our 3 MILLION+ Members Today! Register Here | Login
Login or Register to post comments

37 Comments

Posted by Kevin Michaluk Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 688 days ago

Kevin (aka Ryan Seacrest): Hey Manav, I realize you have been busy on the road traveling for work so just finding the place and time to get your review pounded out was an accomplishment in itself. Not sure how the judges are going to feel about the GSM noise your BlackBerry caused your recording equipment to pick up though. Hopefully the community won't penalize you too much for it when it comes time to vote. Let's check in with the judges.

CrackBerry Idol Judges

Dieter: Dawg! Check the GSM noise, definitely kills the video and no idea what's going on there. Your review is much more professional and I'm glad to see you pointed out the "superapp-style" integration with the rest of the BlackBerry OS, that's definitely the strongest point for this app. Hate to say it, but despite your well-organized review, I think that GSM buzz might keep you from making it to the next round.

Georgia: Hello Manav, I found the feedback in this video quite disruptive and I could not review the video properly. The written review had some sentence structure issues but covered the applications basics. Thank you for adding the various things that this application lacks in comparison to other Twitter clients. I think the poor video may hinder your progress to the next stage of the competition, try to always review your video before you upload it. Good luck.

Craig: Wow that GSM feedback was terrible. Sadly because of it, the video was unwatchable. Maybe you never realized just how loud it was? Definitely check this before posting the video. Your blog post was pretty good and seemed to cover the things I'd care about in such an app. Realizing that English is your second language, I forgave some sentence structure issues.

 
 
Posted by Xopher Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 688 days ago

Man, the video was terrible! Not only was the GSM/feedback really bad, the video was out of focus! It made the entire video experience excruciating. Anytime you brought the BB close to the camera, you couldn't read anything on the screen. At least the "Ums" were at a minimum.

The write-up was much better. I don't know if it is going to be enough to get you to the next round, though.

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Please check my comment below.

 
 
Posted by Kerri Neill Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 688 days ago

My video had to be dark too and isn't as great as I'd have liked even filming in HD. My app had a dark background which meant I had to keep the lights dim.

 
 
Posted by shacknews Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 688 days ago

Wow... Seriously, worst review of anything Ive ever seen in my life. And Ive seen some awful reviews of products on youtube but this takes the cake.

Your first video review was 2nd worse ive ever seen as you just rolled out of bed and decided to make a product review hurr durrr hmmm huu.

Now, this is awful, wow just quit before you out due yourself yet again.

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

OK.

 
 
Posted by alex3305 Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 688 days ago

Just a tip: next time - if there is going to be one - use a freaking wifi signal!

Furthermore, try to talk slowly and calmly so everyone can understand you. If you talk too fast, it looks like your nervous and that sucks. You can have as many takes on the video as you want. So.. peace, quiet and meditate!

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Please read the comment I posted below, thanks for your feedback.

 
 
Posted by yodatom10 Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 688 days ago

I don't have any attention to vote for someone who can't do a video properly don't u watch it before u submit. The written review was ok but nowhere on pare with anyone else. In the end 0.5 stars out of 5 and will almost guarantee elimation. Better luck next time :(

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

I was very aware of the issue with the noise. But did not have any other choice. Please read my comment below.

 
 
Posted by catseyenu Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 688 days ago

What changed from 1.0.0.41 to 1.0.0.45?
Does it still lock up making the phone completely useless until you pull the battery & restart the phone?
BlackBerry App World shows no change log that I can see.

 
 
Posted by JRF_8520 Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 688 days ago

I think the only thing they added was the "Go to user" function. Mine doesn't lock up or anything. It's wierd how some apps work on some phones but not on others. Like Opera Mini 5, doesn't work on my 8520 but on other 8520's it does.

 
 
Posted by arrago Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 687 days ago

this video is unwatchable too much gsm noise very annoying bye!

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Terribly sorry for that.

 
 
Posted by arrago Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 687 days ago

this video is unwatchable too much gsm noise very annoying bye!

 
 
Posted by yASMiN37 Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 687 days ago

video quality is poor as hell please don't bring this guy in the next round im sorry but i didnt understand what he was saying...

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Hey there, please read my explanation below.

 
 
Posted by wirelessgal Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

I'm not trying to be rude, but that video review was terrible! The GSM buzzing noise over powered your voice and I couldn't hear what you were saying. The video quality was pretty bad. Honestly, if I wasn't using T4BB already, this video wouldn't have convinced me to try out the app.

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Please read my explaination regarding the GSM Noise below.

 
 
Posted by trjnberry Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

I tried, to be fair in the feedback process, I really tried to finish that video, but it so annoying and couldn't hear what you were saying. Excellent writeup, but as Kevin said from the start, we live in a Web 2.0 world now, and you have to be able to do video reviews right. Good luck in the competition, but I get a strong impression your CB Idol journey ends with this entry.

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Read the comment I posted below. Thanks for your kind words.

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Hello everyone, thanks for your kind words and criticism its greatly appreciated.

As Kevin mentioned in the first post I did this when travelling, and had no other option. I didn't have a proper camera or access to broadband. It was either this video (or no video at all) which would mean that I would have to drop out of the contest altogether. So please don't judge on the biases of the video.

I'm really sorry for the GSM noise. Thanks for giving me a chance to be a part of this.

 
 
Posted by trjnberry Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Considering your extenuating circumstances and excellent written review, I'd be willing to consider you for the next round. I would hope that your second video review would have the sound problem fixed, but I think your written review shows a lot of potential. I don't use twitter but I found your written review to tell me what I needed to know to consider getting this app.

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Thank you so much for your understanding. And if I make it to the next round, ill make sure there is not video noise :p

 
 
Posted by Diggs31 Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

I wish I had your dedication because I didn't apply because I was travelling. Until we see the quality issues rectified I don't think it would be fair to judge you harshly...other than to say enunciate your words. On camera your accent can garble up words...it could have been the camera you were using but I think it's something worth keeping in mind.

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Yes it was a really crappy camera.

 
 
Posted by Xopher Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

I understand your delema, but this does pose a query. If you are going to be in a position to have to review things on the fly, are you going to be prepared to put out professional reviews and videos?

When Kevin heads out on trips, he takes is good mic for recording podcasts, he has a video cameras for taking videos. They leave prepared to handle the situation.

My point being that you knew this contest was going on (you submitted your initial entry), yet you left unprepared for for it. What is going to happen if you make it past this round and have to head out again? Will you be prepared to handle the next video properly, or are we going to have to suffer through the possibility of future reviews with the same quality? Is ignoring a portion of your submission fair to the other contestants?

 
 
Posted by don_poky Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

I agree with xopher as always lol, I'm sure he did receive to do a video review on an app a couple days ago before deadline so even webcams are good too. If you used ur webcam here u would make it brighter environment.

As Xopher said you have to be ready with things if you are travelling and really want to be a CB Idol.

TIP: Twitter worked on WiFi after logged in.

But except all you did cover basic and some good points with the review.

Be a Indian Hero in the next round LOL ... good luck

 
 
Posted by trjnberry Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

I was thinking the same thing about the travelling angle and being prepared for the contest. I think some of these contestants are not realizing that the top prize is a job, it's not just a free Blackberry or some BB goodies. This contest is a tryout to join the Crackberry Team. I was expecting professional reviews and showcases of talent, and some of these entries have been outright disappointing. I don't want to read a review on the blog that starts with a lame infomerical or insults the readership or sounds like an amateur YouTube video. These are acceptable entries for a typical Crackberry summer contest, but I'd expect more from a prospective regular contributor to the Crackberry blog.

I am hoping that the later rounds will showcase that professionalism and talent that I have come to expect from the Crackberry Team. I have only seen two or three reviews so far that have that potential. Manav did an excellent written review, but the reason I willing to consider a vote for him is I haven't seen enough Crackberry Blog worthy reviews, imo, that will fill 10 votes. So, I got one to spare for him, so far.

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

When I found out and from that time till little after the DEADLINE I was on the road, without proper Internet (was using a crappy GPRS access card) or a camera.

I've already considered myself out because of the video, but thanks to crack berry for the oppturnity and everyone here for their dialogue.

 
 
Posted by cutdacheck2003 Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

The written portion of this review was excellent in my opinion. My problem with the video noise was that I was really interested in seeing someone use "twitter for blackberry" and explain why it should be used vs any other twitter app. I wasn’t able to hear you over the noise to evaluate at all. Even though I wanted to view this video outside of the contest which I wasn’t concerned about, in all fairness I think if the video was unable to be conducted like it should have been based on the written review you should have just been exceptioned to the next round and had a chance to try again. This is not your livelihood Im sure and life happens for most of us outside of crackberry. Good Luck!

 
 
Posted by manav Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Thanks man, glad you liked it!

 
 
Posted by don_poky Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

Please someone care to tell me Dieter's full name (on eof the judge's)

 
 
Posted by cdf3 Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

I only watched about half of the review before I ended up shutting it down. I couldn't take the video noise, and the video quality wasn't good either. I could barely see what was going on. I'm still fairly new to the Blackberry Twitter app. I was hoping this was going to be a very informative review for me. I was disappointed.

 
 
Posted by manav Friday, Jul 09, 2010 686 days ago

I'm sorry for the GSM Noise, please read my explanation in the comments above.

 
 
Posted by BB.girl92 Thursday, Jul 08, 2010 687 days ago

The video was really good the first like 30 seconds or so, but once that noise started I had to turn it off =[ Your write-up was pretty good! I just hope that the GSM noise didn't hinder your chances of moving to the next round!! Good job though!!

 
 
Posted by manav Friday, Jul 09, 2010 686 days ago

Hey Britt,

Thanks for your thumbs-up, the video sticks out like a sore thumb though :p. Best of luck to you as well. I'm sure you're making it to the next round.