Join Our 3 MILLION+ Members Today! Register Here | Login
Login or Register to post comments

42 Comments

Posted by Kevin Michaluk Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Kevin (aka Ryan Seacrest): Nice review there Shankeith. LOVE that driving music in the video..hahahaha. You definitely showed your knowledge of the application. Let's see what the judges have to say about it...

CrackBerry Idol Judges

Dieter: What's up dawg? Solid review. I like what you did with it. Sure the video was a bit long, but the hardcore CrackBerry readers who are really seriously considering going with Telenav as their solution will appreciate the length. The written review covered the key points well - my only complaint here is that the sections you broke the article down in to are not what an individual may normally expect. That makes it the type of review you have to read from start to finish - you can't quickly glance and find the details you are looking for. It was also a little short on links.

Georgia: Really appreciated that you took a drive, using the application. This gave us a good idea of how the application will be used. I did find it a bit disconcerting seeing the phone bounce around... I got dizzy after a min or two. The video was a bit long (8 minutes), try being more concise. I found myself being distracted after about 5 minutes of video, could have used more pizzazz. I enjoyed how you gave your own feelings on the application. The completeness of the review showed that you really got to know the application before reviewing it. Well done.

Craig: I kind of liked where I thought you were going, but you didn't quite pull it off as I was hoping. Your video went too long for covering a single app. Maybe for a device review you can justify 8+ minutes, but unless you included some dancing ladies in this one to keep the entertainment value there for the CrackBerry audience I think half the length would have been about right (this one had me feeling like I might get car sick). I liked your audition video and this first review from you definitely follows it up and proves you have the stuff to be in the running here. The written review was good, but all I really want to know is what it does, does it do it well and should I buy it. I got a tad bored towards the end. That said, I do realize this is a competition so every contestantant is going to max out their reviews. Good effort for sure.

 
 
Posted by shankeith Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

thanks guys for the constructive criticism, just basically the take away from this is that my review has to be shorter and concise. i guess short and sweet, i'll keep that in mind for the next review.

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Wednesday, Jun 30, 2010 695 days ago

ShanKeith, I like your passion and knowledge about the device(s) and apps, but I found the video waaaaayy too long, just like your audition video felt too long.

I agree with Craig, adding a few dancing girls might have helped. ;)

Again, best wishes on advancing. Good stuff all around.

 
 
Posted by joeygoggles Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Good, informative review. I now can see what this has to offer for a BB GPS solution. Unfortunately, until a free turn by turn app is released it's too hard to leave Tom Tom and their free maps for life.

 
 
Posted by sunrisepromo Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I just started using Telenav a few weeks ago and I like it better than the standard GPS units you can buy for your vehicle. It's so convenient to have it all on your BlackBerry and I've had no issues in getting to where I need to go with it.

 
 
Posted by BBThemes Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

like the review, what i really like is the comparison to its competition, plus the integration options.

yea the vid is slightly on the longer side, but this is sat nav, not a quick game or app that you can just sit there with, the drive really showed the app at its best.

diggin the colorware BB too :)

 
 
Posted by ahaz86 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I agree with dave, i felt that the length of the video was justified as he was taking us on a drive and showed how well the application worked.

As a whole the review was extremely informative, and you could tell that he knew the product he was reviewing well.

Great review, hope there are more this good!

 
 
Posted by BlackBerrySpot.com Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I had a chance to read over this review. I use TeleNav on a daily basis and this review couldn't have been more accurate. Shan did a fantastic job going over all of the great parts of the software and being a good reviewer means being unbiased; Shan also did a great job of telling the cons without making the program unappealing. I look forward to reading more of his fantastic reviews!

 
 
Posted by evb624 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I think it was a good review. The video was a little long. When i saw 8 minutes i decided to just read the review (4 minutes of so would have been perfect as I have a short attention span). This review actually made me want to try it myself, and I must say I like it better then my Garmin system. All of the finalist so have have done good reviews so far. Keep up the good work guys...and girls.

 
 
Posted by Rockafella Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Crackberry had (5) 1yr subscriptions to give away back in March and I was one of the winners. All I can say is that is has been the absolute perfect GPS application for me. I do have a stand alone GPS but the software is from 2008 (outdated). Garmin wants $75 to update it. I can almost get a brand new GPS unit for that price. As far as telenav, it has been great for me. I use it all the time. Just last week, I took a long road trip (California --->Virginia). Took me 2.5 days but along the way I wanted to stop at specific hotels and telenav would help me get there. I would also break it out every once in awhile so it could tell me how far away I was to a specific destination I wanted to make it to for the evening. I'm currently still in Virginia and it works good to find specific places I want to visit. Thank you again TeleNav for picking me as one of the winners. It has surely save me $$$.

 
 
Posted by Hamp Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I understand the convenience of having an all-in-one device, I mean, that's one of the things we love about our BB! Telenav is a great app but as joeygoggles stated until a FREE turn by turn voice app is released, I can't see the point of paying $9.99/mo when my Garmin does the same thing w/o a monthly free. What you pay for in a year with Telenav could go towards a decent in-vehicle device if all you want is the voice feature.

Just my two cents.

 
 
Posted by mpenn4077 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

depends on your carrier. If you have sprint, telenav (rebranded as sprint navigation) is actually included in all data packs for blackberry for no extra charge

 
 
Posted by Kerri Neill Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Sprint Nav is spotty at best. I find it much easier to use my TomTom rather then mess with Sprint Navigation. I tried using it in a rental car while in Texas a few months back & several times I had to turn around because the maps were wrong.

 
 
Posted by arist01 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I had Telenav on my Storm2 and really liked the integration with the BB menu. However, I had to cancel after having an open ticket that could not be resolved.

The Speak In Search function does not work, or at least consistently, on Storm2. Its a known bug and they have a different Storm2 version that is supposed to resolve that problem. It didn't work.

That, coupled with the fact that Telenav defaults the keyboard in Portrait mode to multi-tap (my setting is SureType) makes it hard to input an address while driving. I use a cradle and need to either quickly type in an address or speak it.

Spent tons of time with tech support with no luck.

Hope they get it fixed soon. I prefer Telenav to Garmin for the UI and I actually like the pay per month set up vs buying an app that I can't port to a new device.

Also, for those who use their BB as an in-car MP3 player via the headset jack...you will be disappointed. The voice commands under navigation stop media play. You have to manually restart, and the music stops the next time a command is issued. Would be nice if it paused media play, played the command, and then re-started media play. Maybe that's asking too much from a phone app but it would be nice.

 
 
Posted by Rooster99 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

This is part comment, part question.

Comment 1 :
I had Telenav for just over a year and liked it. Then from Sep 2009 to Jan 2010 it was broken. In that time it had to be re-installed by Telus twice (OTA remotely of course), and when the final problem hit, Telus finally acknowledged it was broken for many Telenav clients and they had no idea when it would be fixed. I gave up and bought Garmin software and have been very happy.

Comment 2 :
One of the additional reasons I went Garmin is Telenav seemed limited to North America, and I also wanted European maps. I may have been incorrect on this point but it's something to look into.

Comment 3 :
Garmin sells software for the Berry that is about $90, making the actual Telenav/Garmin break even approx 9 months, not 35.

Question :
Is Telenav now more reliable on Telus?

Thanks - R.

 
 
Posted by shankeith Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

i really cant answer that question because im with rogers

 
 
Posted by that_maynard Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

It had a lot of detail which was great, but maybe a bit long, video and written review. I have Sprint, so GPS with voice is included with my data plan, but for others you did a great job describing the app. Kudos, you know your stuff! :) Not to sound mean, but I did fast forward to see what happened after the drive, I did like the music though.

 
 
Posted by LOZ Girl Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I thought this review was DULL. It was too much information all crammed into one review. The video was way too long and only held my interest for the first minute or so. The only thing I liked about this review was the music during the drive but even that got old real quick.

 
 
Posted by Scream_At_Chaboi Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I've been using Telenav since the Nextel days 2005-2006. Telenav runs great on the Blackberry. However, the biggest con is the monthly subscription. That sucks $120 a year.

 
 
Posted by dhack21 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Shankeith definitely gets my vote. His review is well rounded, informative, and short. Not too much to read yet it informed me of the product. Also, not to mention that he has been part of the crackberry forums for a few years now and has experience building themes to boot!

 
 
Posted by Lumberman Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Just to start I liked the review. Sure the video was on the long side but everything you need to know is also in writing.

My comment is regarding what everyone seems to be missing when making the statement that you can have everything on one device. I am not sure about the paid for apps but as far as Google Maps goes, if you don't have cell service you don't have navigation. Google Maps downloads the maps as it needs them, if this is not true of Telenav or Garmin or other paid apps then I apologize but it seems unlikely that software that has a monthly subscription would have all the maps stored on board the device, plus I think that would tie up a lot of precious memory.

So if you are in the mountains where there is no service, or somewhere where you don't get data...then you don't get maps, true?

 
 
Posted by BBNewbie2010 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

The video wasn't that long IMO, it was in depth from start to finish along with the written review. Top notch.

 
 
Posted by mkmilan Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Wonder how they match up ....

 
 
Posted by mangcool Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Very nice review. Very clear, informative, and I really enjoyed it!

 
 
Posted by SGDELAME8310 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I have found if you look on Telenav's website and your equipment is not showing a carrier specific nav listed. Telenav sells a 48 month plan for $249.99 (upfront $5.19/month) for the AT&T Bold 9000. For VZW most of the current phones are eligible.

 
 
Posted by mikeinpa Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Maybe I missed this in the review, but if your phone rings, does it take you out of the nav program? And if it does, does the program have to be manually restarted or does it restart automatically? I tend to get most of my business calls while I am driving, so it would interfere to much with my navigation.

 
 
Posted by shankeith Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

sorry, i should have mentioned this, but the popup is within telenav and then when your done the call you can hangup and it starts off where you left

 
 
Posted by cinghoa Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

The main screen on this app looks almost identical to the Sprint nav that came preloaded on my Curve.
I'm at work, so I can't watch the video, but many things seem similar. The Sprint version did have some hiccups finding some things in KC, but other than that, I was pretty happy with it. If you have Sprint, give it a try. If not, enjoy Telenav. Thanks for the review.

 
 
Posted by Imayam Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Kinda Boring.

 
 
Posted by adam80460 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Nice review bro.... I didnt find it boring at all.. actually it was very informative. The way you showed it in action by driving around, was the perfect way to show it off...Me Likey :)

 
 
Posted by jlb21 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I liked the review. If I needed a GPS app I would heavily consider Telenav now.

But what I would really like to know, who was filming the Berry while you were driving????? :)

 
 
Posted by shankeith Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

my brother did!

 
 
Posted by trjnberry Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I have used VZ Navigator (Verizon's Navigator service) for so long that I could have bought 3 stand-alone GPS units with my subscription dues! Haha! But, I love the convenience of having a navigator on the phone. I share Georgia's perspective for this entry about the distracting video and motion sickness of the car scene. I think a close-up shot of the menus as you were going through them would have been more helpful for the viewer.

On your written review, I appreciated your screen shots to help me get a sense of what this app does. I wish you would have covered the pros and cons of using a navigator on your phone. For example, how do you handle calls when you're using your navigator? Does the call shut off the navigator or are you unable to answer a call when you got the navigator running?

One convenience I like with phone navigators is the ability to use the program when outside the car, like in walking neighborhoods or riding in a friend's car or taxi. With a stand-alone unit, you have an extra device to charge, to carry, to worry about losing, breaking or getting it stolen. Spend any decent time on the Crackberry forums, and you'll get a strong impression that Blackberry users don't like to spend money on pricy apps. Might be an idea to compare to free apps. For example, I once tried the free LifeinPocket GPS app in an area that I was unfamilar with and I got lost. I jumped on my VzNavigator and found the place in short time. Paying $10 a month for the phone navigator is worth it to me. Include an example like this in your review and you may get those on the fence to bite and try it out. Anyhow, look forwarding to your next review. Good luck in contest.

 
 
Posted by dixon11 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

You pretty much passed right by my house!

 
 
Posted by RetroAndreas Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I've been using TeleNav with my Tour for almost a year with Bell.

Here is a tip(didn't watch the video so if its there I apologize)

I went to TelNav's US site and logged in as "other" for my carrier.
Gave them my phone # and they gave me a pin number.
I then installed plugins for my browsers (both PC & Mac).
All I need to do is highlight the address and hit the plugin icon in my browser. Select the address from a list and the address goes into my phones fav section after i hit refresh button.

Works Great!

 
 
Posted by speedyV Wednesday, Jun 30, 2010 695 days ago

I don't know if they are doing this just for me, but either way I feel all telenav users should know!

I emailed about canceling my subscription got to pricey. Had an email that said for a limited time we will only charge you $4.99 a month for the next 6 months for your subscription.

PIN me I can see if I can locate the email from them. This was only like last month. Not sure if I should just throw this email out in public or not.

3105C407

Thanks

And YES GREAT REVIEW!! I use this app almost on a daily basis. With a car stand thing I purchased from Best-Buy for I think 11.99

 
 
Posted by JMDBERRY Wednesday, Jun 30, 2010 695 days ago

My Nav sys on my X5 is on the brinks,..as it will not read the DVD! I'm sure BMW will want a pretty penny to replace or repair the unit. I'm leaning to add T-by-T GPS navigation to my BB 9700 as a means to not have to rely on a car mfr's Nav system. Another reason is that I'll have the latest updates as I use the TeleNav system,...my X5 has the 2005 DVD,...I'm sure they have built more roads since then,...as well as possibly re-named a few streets here and there. All-the-same, I'm leaning towards a mobile Nav sys after reading and watching this review,...great work, and don't worry abt some saying that the review was too long,...especially since you decided use time to go a bit more indepth about the features of TeleNav! Your efforts have been greatly appreciated here...

JMDBerry
...Have Bold Will Travel~

 
 
Posted by Jerry5k Wednesday, Jun 30, 2010 695 days ago

You can purchase Garmin/mobile for a one time charge of $99.00.(a little less sometimes) The App is good for the life of your cellphone. In most cases if you change phones in the first year Garmin will allow you to move the application to the new phone. (note- if you change phones after two years you would have only paid $50/yr for the Garmin vs $120/yr for the Telnav.

I had Telnav prior to purchasing Garmin/mobile. About the only difference between the two is Garmin will also show your speed that you are traveling. Both have up-to-date maps,no downloading of current maps required.

Would like to see an independent comparison between the two APPs so a potential buyer can make the choice on what would be best for them.

 
 
Posted by svanelet Thursday, Jul 01, 2010 694 days ago

Your review was very informative and concise, though you could mention that you can go on your computer and look up addresses online rather than from your phone. Then, you can sync those addresses to your phone. This can be done at:

http://my.telenav.com

The video was a bit long and the GPS was shaky, but otherwise good.

 
 
Posted by Xopher Wednesday, Jun 30, 2010 695 days ago

I have to agree that the video seemed a little long. It may not have been for the amount of detail being shown throughout the app, but the mellow/monotone voice just made it seem longer. The only real complaint I have about the video is that the BlackBerry was too far away from the camera when you were holding it. I couldn't read anything on the screen, and there really isn't a need to show your keyboard (or hand moving across the trackpad). It would have been better if the screen took up more of the video space.

The write-up was very good. My nit-picking pet-peeve about software reviews: you didn't specify the file size for the download. Some BlackBerry users might be interested if it is a 500K download, but not if it is a 5MB download. Knowing how large the file size is can help people decide if it is worth downloading.

 
 
Posted by Iz Wednesday, Jun 30, 2010 695 days ago

I have been using TeleNav since late 2008. I love the app. I use it daily. I am a Sprint customer and have used it for my users and self for a couple of years now. The only issue I have with TeleNav is customer support. I have had issue (not and again) when I swap devices, getting the TeleNav on the new device. Trying to get things resolved through TeleNav is often very time consuming and frustrating. That being said...even with this I choose to use this application on all of my personal devices and many of my BES devices. Easier than TomTom or Garmlin and I never have to plug in and update.

Great App!!

 
 
Posted by katiepea Thursday, Jul 01, 2010 694 days ago

this is a great app for blackberry users, it's shamefully worse than whats offered for free on android with google navigation being what it is, and free at that, but if you're on blackberry platform this is by far the best navigation option, and works well.