Smartphone Round Robin: WinMo Dieter Goes Bold!

on 18 Nov 2008 03:38 AM

[ This is an official Smartphone Round Robin post! Every day you reply to an official Round Robin blog post or forum thread on CrackBerry.com, you automatically gain an entry ballot for a chance to win a BlackBerry Bold, Spare Bold Battery, and Case Mate Second Skin! ]

It makes my heart hurt a little to see my BlackBerry Bold in somebody else's hands, but I'm at least happy to see WMExperts Dieter's first impressions of the Bold are quite postive. Dieter likes the hardware, loves the Bold's display (he'd be crazy not to!), and was more than happy with the snappiness of the 624mHz processor. But as a hardcore Windows Mobile guy, Dieter still found a few things to nitpick on the Bold and BlackBerry platform. Click the image above to head on over to WMExperts.com and see Dieter's video hands-on.

Keep in mind, posting your daily Round Robin comment at CrackBerry.com gives you a chance to win a BlackBerry Bold + Accesories. But if you login to WMExperts.com and post a comment, you'll have a chance to win an HTC Fuse + Celio Red Fly Mobile Companion.

And if by chance you still don't know what all this Smartphone Round Robin stuff is all about, do yourself a favor and click this link!

Filed Under: SPE Round Robin;

195 Comments

Posted by thegooz Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

First

Posted by bB03 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I would like to know how many participants change their level of affection for their previous devices. Maybe even switching from one device to another after the round robin is complete. Be honest!

Posted by cvaria Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1181 days ago

The flow make her fatty shake, patty cake, patty cake
For fake, if he was Anita Baker's man
He'd take her for her masters, hit it once an' shake her hand
On some ol' thank ya ma'am an' ghost her
She could mind the toaster if she sign the poster
A whole host of roller coaster riders
Not enough tracks (is it?)
Hot enuff black (for ya)

Posted by FrickinRob Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I have to say that the last Windows Mobile device I used was through T-Mobile with the HTC Excalibur, or Dash. It was my first smartphone, and absolutely loved it throughout the time that I had it. It wasn't until I got my first Blackberry, though, that I felt like I was using a professional device that did everything I needed it to do on a daily basis..and it did it well. I've become pretty spoiled by push e-mail, and I could never (not even for a month of round robin fun) go back to having to refresh every five minutes to check my e-mail.

Posted by telejeff Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1181 days ago

Having to pull your email is such a waste of time. It's kind of like before you had a smart phone and you would constantly go on the computer to check your email. It's just plain unproductive. It's helpful to let the emails poor and have your hip vibrate. I can quickly see who and what it is then decide if its worth responding to this very second or later.

Posted by Bla1ze Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Dieter is slowly, but surely becoming a BlackBerry addict, if it was'nt for the issues with IMAP, I'd say he'd already be deep into an addiction lol.

Posted by Rene Ritchie Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Hey, fair is fair, you began the collectibles market for Dieter's laptop, now he's begun the same for your Bold.

Like Emilio Estevez, you're making each other famous. :)

Posted by chakejaam Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

My heart would be a little out of wack too if someone ELSE had my phone. but then again, i dont have a bold yet. lol

Posted by detfan Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

This was supposed to be BBB review, they guy would not shut up about his WM phone. Did not like it at all. WM sucks, period!!

Posted by taralouise Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

i wonder how many of these people end up secret blackberry lovers after this is all over with... especially since they are gonna be using the bold.

this guy is fighting it, but the bold is winning him over.

Posted by BBpixie Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I've seen a friend go between a treo and a bb, eventually he fell in love with the bb. Yayyy!

Posted by driwashsolutions Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

If the BOLD were available on VZW, I'd definitely consider it - but I'm not going to leave VZW for it.

Posted by latinatwix28 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

The bold is fantastic.. im in love each day with it..and makes my job easier...

Posted by Sal Morreale Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Looks cool! Can't wait.

Posted by BBpixie Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I originally am waiting to grab the BB 8900 once it comes out in either Canada or the US, but seeing how people are commenting on the Bold, I'm starting to think I should get the Bold! If I win the Bold, I can finally put in my pros and cons. I know instantly the con for me is the kbd but the pro would be I'd say the 3G and everything else!!

Posted by movieguy00 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Suprised that messing around with the Bold wouldn't instantly change someones mind and make them want to keep it.

Posted by dcmom Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Hope Dieter will enjoy all that the Bold has to offer.

Posted by rrrebo Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I desperately want to Storm, but I need to put my hands on it first to see how one-handed operation is. I can live without wi-fi, but 3G I think is going to be a must. I won't switch to Verizon for it, either, so I will have to wait it out and hope the AT&T GSM version has 3G.

As for the Bold, it is very much on my immediate want list. My wife and I have first-gen 8300 Curves. Her trackball click sensor is completely dead, and she won't let me send it in. I am simply ready to move up to the Bold since I cannot get the Storm.

Now, if the economy would just pick up a bit...

Posted by dstrauss Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

...that a WIndows Mobile user review of the Bold would drive me back into the arms of Blackberry! I was really impressed with Dieter's review, particualrly the speed of the OS and the great screen on this device. I just wish it were in a Curve size package...

Posted by biggem001 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Oh, the bold, i cannot wait!! i want one soo bad!

Posted by VoltaicShock Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

He makes a remark that there are not enough "Multiple hardware button shortcuts."

If he turned off dial from home, then he would have a plethora of shortcuts.

Posted by Anonymous Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I think this is a great idea of everyone testing the others device. It shows you what you like about your favorite platform and improvements that the others have. A great idea and has been fun reading the reviews of all the phones. Great Job!

Posted by HuskyHawk Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I agree with Dieter on the buttons. Take a look at the Nokia E71, that is the ideal, right there. Perfect Hardware. Too bad it runs S60. But the idea of buttons next to a D pad that are dedicated to email, calendar and contacts...how perfect a fit is that with the whole Blackberry experience. Yet RIM has never done it. I'm a Blackberry user, but I recognize the strengths of other platforms, including WinMo. I also think a D pad would be a big improvement over the trackball, which I still don't like.

Posted by mickeydee Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

My music theory/band director says I'm obsessed with my BlackBerry... I can't say that I think he's lying, because I absolutely LOVE my BlackBerry : )! The obsession would only grow if I had a bold!

Posted by maverick262 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

What I would do to get me a bold, especially a FREE one, haha!

Posted by ecooper11 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Please pick me to win the Bold!

Posted by ecooper11 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Please pick me to win the Bold!

Posted by ingrassia Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I know what he is really thinking! " Do you think Kevin would be mad if I started my own Blackberry site?"

Posted by pdone Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

25th!!!

Posted by ingrassia Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I dont know if begging works with Kevin but for a BOLD and to be able to go 3G!!!!! this is me begging! (if begging does not work for you disregard this!)

Posted by bryanharig Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

If nothing else he is going to love the battery life and stability when compared to WM.

Posted by kasperapd Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Glad you are liking the Bold

Posted by dhall13 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

oooooohhhhhhhhhhhh, look at that device!!! How can you ever go back to a WM Device?????????

Posted by manttium Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Nothing gives me more satisfaction than a snappy UI with no lag. I think he'll be very impressed with the Bold. I only hope the folks at Waterloo iron out the OS going into the Storm and it gets a bit quicker!

Posted by JSho101 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Looks like he's having a BOLD experience with your BlackBerry :)

Posted by kristins Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

during the Smartphone Round Robin! Convert 'em!

Posted by Wade Bloggs Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I need that Blackberry Bold in my life.
Damn T-mobile!!!!!
I'm torn between getting an Unlocked bold, or just waiting for the 8900. any ideas?

Posted by SOADFreak1989 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I love the bold's screen. I picked up one at Bestbuy to play with and I thought it was a sticker on the screen but when i moved the trackball, the screen responded. I was shocked how crystal clear the screen was. Absolutely phenominal.

Posted by ecooper11 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Please pick me to win the Bold!

Posted by ecooper11 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

Please pick me to win the Bold!

Posted by Chriton Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

In the opening it sounded like he had a crush on the Bold.... as he should

Posted by Queen4111 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I like the BB Bold.
Hopefully, the US Fed Govt will upgrade to this.
We're still using BB 8700's!

Posted by Dimietriev Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I think Dieter has a good point when he mentions that it can get a little crazy with the settings, at least for a person new to blackberry. It could be a little overwhelming at first.

Posted by Jabb Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

convert him!

Posted by nosferatumephisto Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

For me, the WM experience was a little while ago, I think that BB Bold will head the other devices.

Posted by amichaels04 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

htc fuze would be nice but the bold is better!

Posted by Tpony Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

What a great thing to do! I'm excited to watch all the reviews. Though no matter the reviews I love my Bold! Thanks CrackBerry for the great articles!

Posted by aclark Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

I could certainly use a second one!

Posted by gfco321 Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

One thing i do agree with the guys from WMexperts.com is the lack of a "home screen" in blackberry devices. Some may say that the "today" theme can double as that. but it just doesnt display enought information.

I would like to see a home screen with more than the last two received emails and appointments. it should be customizable. maybe include facebook and myspace notifications (for the social focused user);what about including the memopad or tasks feature on that home screen aswell...

any thoughts on this?

Posted by sirliang Tuesday, Nov 18, 2008 1182 days ago

i'm not picky... bold or storm... just gimme one.