Smartphone Round Robin: Goodbye BlackBerry, Hello Windows Mobile and the ATT Tilt

By Kevin Michaluk on 30 Oct 2007 05:41 pm EDT
0
loading...
0
loading...
0
loading...

AT&T Tilt
Week #1 Device: AT&T Tilt by HTC

My First Impressions of the Windows Mobile Powered AT&T Tilt

It was two weeks and four days ago when Dieter had the idea for Smartphone Experts to hold its First Annual Smartphone Round Robin. I heard about the concept only minutes after it was originally conceived, and since that moment began mentally readying myself for the challenge of putting my CrackBerry Addiction on hold for the better part of a month in favor of sampling three other types of smartphone ‘candy’ in the form of Windows Mobile, Palm Treo, and Apple iPhone devices. It was decided that Week #1 of the Round Robin would see me using the Windows Mobile powered AT&T Tilt (made by HTC). Think I'll get through it? Click Here to Find out!

Don't forget, a comment to this post counts as an entry in the Round Robin Contest! Be sure you're logged in before you comment. 

Initial Experience with the AT&T Tilt

Taking Delivery
I was out for lunch on Friday when the Fedex man tried to drop off the Tilt. I called Fedex to find out when I could pick it up from their depot and just managed to get there before they closed for the night. Sitting in the dark (still in the Fedex parking lot), I ripped open the package to get my first look at it. When I finally got through the tape and bubble wrap, out came a dark, dense... BRICK. That was my first impression of the Tilt in one word – brick – which for me isn’t a bad thing. By BlackBerry standards the old 7200 and 8700s are bricks as well, and that sturdy/heavy feeling is one of the things I actually miss in the Curve. But damn, the small size/heavy weight ratio present in the Tilt honestly gives it the immediate impression that you’re holding something more akin to a dumbbell than an electronic gadget. If you had two of them (one for each hand) you could exercise your way into a half decent physique.

Goodbye BlackBerry
When I finally rolled out of bed on Saturday (Friday was Halloween Party night) I was ready to take the plunge and try and embrace Windows Mobile. I said my tearful goodbye to my beloved BlackBerry, pulled the battery cover off, and was JUST about to pull the battery and my SIM card out when I was struck for the first time by a nasty realization… that the second I pulled the SIM card out of my BlackBerry I would be without BlackBerry Messenger for three weeks. If you’re not familiar with BlackBerry Messenger (you can learn about it here) it’s essentially a BlackBerry to BlackBerry instant messaging program that runs on RIM’s network. Think threaded SMS, except free, faster, and just plain old better. The only problem is that your BlackBerry Messenger identification is tied to your BlackBerry device’s unique PIN number. To experience the send/receive of BlackBerry Messenger you need to have a BlackBerry. I sent a quick email to all of my BlackBerry Messenger contacts letting them know I would be without BlackBerry Messenger for the month, and with a nervous twitch proceeded to yank the battery and SIM card out of my Curve.

Goodbye BlackBerry, Hello Tilt
The Saddest Moment of My BlackBerry Life - This photo was taken
moments before I pulled the SIM card out of the Curve...

Device Overview
From previous reading on the Tilt, I knew the device I was now going to use for a week was feature rich. GPS, WiFi and a Camera w/ video recording in one device is still a dream in the BlackBerry world. Though I knew the Tilt’s feature list was impressive, what I didn’t realize until holding it in my hand was just how many input options the Tilt offered: full qwerty slide out keyboard, a BlackBerry-style trackwheel on the left side (with ‘ok’ button underneath), multi-direction navigation and control buttons on the front and a touch screen. Thinking back to my BlackBerry which really offers only one means of control (trackball/trackwheel to navigate and keyboard to enter data) but is just so darn easy and efficient to use, I wasn’t really convinced that the smörgåsbord of input options offered by the Tilt would make the device any easier to use. More isn’t always better.

Holding the device in my hand I was impressed by the Tilt’s build quality. I can now see why HTC enjoys the reputation that it does. I do think maybe the heaviness of the phone bolsters this feeling  of quality (I’m pretty sure the gadget world associates lightweight electronics with being ‘cheap’ and heavy electronics with being ‘well-built’) but either way the device seems well constructed and put together.

Battery, SIM and Media Card Installation
Seems like it should be easy, right? For me that wasn’t quite the case. Of the three, Media Card installation was the most intuitive (I could see it at the bottom of the phone as it was externally accessible – nice!) so I did that first. I tossed in a 4GB MicroSDHC card. Flipping the phone around in my hands looking for a way to pull the phone’s back cover off (I assumed both the battery and SIM card holder would be located under here) I stumbled upon a very little ‘ridge’ on the bottom right hand corner of the phone. I pulled at it and out came a stylus! I was actually shocked. As mentioned, my experience with smartphones other than the BlackBerry is limited, and I had no idea this thing would use a stylus. I actually laughed – in my mind a stylus seems beyond ‘old school’. At least HTC’s integration of the stylus into the phone is amazingly seemless. Honestly, if you didn’t know the phone had a stylus you could probably use it for a month before stumbling upon it.

Can you see the Stylus?
Can you see the stylus? It's there..I swear! MicroSD port is at the
bottom covered with the removable rubber cap

The folks at HTC are clever! It turns out the SIM card holder is not located under the battery but is underside the portion of the display that ‘slides’ out. At this point I actually felt a bit of envy towards the Tilt. On my BlackBerry Curve I have to remove the battery to access the SIM and MicroSD card, but the Tilt offers individual access to each. So there it was, I finally had the battery, SIM and media card installed and was now ready to power the device on.

SIM Card
The SIM card has its own locaton under the Slide Out Screen,
and not under the Battery

First Time Full Power Up
Powering up the device, I enjoyed the initial flashed-up AT&T, 3G, Windows Mobile intro screens (very snazzy and with sound effects). And I experienced another flash of sorts, this time a flashback, when the OS loaded up ‘Tap to Align Screen’. Until that moment I had totally forgot that back in 2002 I had purchased a Toshiba e740 Pocket PC. It ran on Microsoft’s Pocket PC 2002 OS and it too used a stylus for input. I thought having a Pocket PC would help me better organize my life back then (was attending University), but after actually using it for three weeks I ultimately abandoned it as I felt I spent more time trying to organize my life on the device than I spent actually living it (it’s still sitting in my basement looking brand new if anyone wants to buy it!).

Suffice to say, I remembered how to use the stylus and got through the little tutorial in a few seconds and continued on with the initial device setup. Setup progressed easily (enter date/time/password) until the phone decided to reboot without warning (it happened just after the  “Installing Menu_Operation.xml” message went away). I immediately thought, “oh yeah…Windows”, but the reboot didn’t take long and I quickly came to the Windows Mobile 6 Today Screen.

Windows Mobile Today Screen
Booted Up and Ready for Use

First Device Use
Every new mobile device has a learning curve. It even took me a day to get used to the BlackBerry’s trackball navigation when I made the switch over from the trackwheel-equipped 8700. But with the Tilt I honestly did not even know how to begin using the device. Should I pull out the slider keyboard? Should I pull out the stylus? Should I try tapping the screen with my thumb? Or index finger? Should I keep the keyboard slid ‘in’ and use the navigation buttons at the bottom of the screen? I am coming over from a BlackBerry… maybe I should use the trackwheel? As I contemplated all of these options the display turned off. I tapped the main ‘enter’ button on the front of the phone without thinking, expecting the device would come out of standby but to my surprise it did not. I hit the talk button, pushed in the trackwheel, tapped all of the keys on the keyboard (it was slid out)… still nothing. Only when I hit the tiny little power button on the right hand side of the phone did the display power back up.

How Do I Turn it On?
Can you find the Power On button?
It's the little wee button with the red circle on it
located under the Page Down key.

At this point I quit taking notes and decided to just use the thing. That’s what most mobile users do and I figured that was the only way I would really be able to learn what this device had to offer.

First Impressions of the AT&T Tilt

Three days and many hours of one-on-one time later, I am now getting to know the Tilt pretty well…

Hands On Usage
I am still confused as to what’s the most efficient way to ‘use’ the device at any given time (as in which input method gets the job done fastest/easiest on any given screen). I’d really like to watch how an experienced Tilt/Windows Mobile user would go about completing a variety of tasks on the phone. At this point it seems to me that executing tasks (i.e. making a call, replying to an email, changing wireless settings, adding a contact, taking a picture and emailing it to another address, etc.) take a lot longer to accomplish on the Tilt than on the BlackBerry. I’m not talking necessarily about the number of keystrokes or clicks it takes to do things, as I’m sure there are instances on each phone where one has a shorter path than the other, but the actual amount of time involved in getting the job done.

With the Tilt it seems like you’re constantly moving your hands around – either sliding the keyboard out or pushing the keyboard in, or moving your hands up to the touchscreen or down to the keyboard, or pulling the stylus out or putting the stylus back in. The Tilt has a really big keyboard, which felt nice to type on at first but which I quickly came to realize is just plain old inefficient – compared to typing on a BlackBerry keyboard you have to physically move your thumbs much further left and right to hit all the keys. The additional physical distance you have to overcome on a big keyboard is definitely detrimental to average words per minute (WPM). I found the position of the ! @  ? keys to be awkward as well, considering that to access them you need to use the Function Key located very close below. It makes for some awkward movements.

I’m finding the Tilt to very much be a two-handed device. With a BlackBerry you only need two hands when typing on the full qwerty, but other than that everything is done with one hand. With the Tilt, other than when you are on the phone talking, you pretty much need to use both hands to hold and navigate the device.

I still figure that I am doing something wrong and there must be an ‘optimal’ way to use the Tilt. I really hope in the next day or two a Windows Mobile expert shows me that way otherwise I’m going to conclude that more input options is definitely not better.

Windows Mobile 6.0 OS
The Windows Mobile operating system didn’t pull any big surprises on me. Don’t get me wrong, I am finding LOTS of little things that irk me the wrong way, which I will get into later as well as in the forums, but in general the OS is pretty easy to use, especially if you are at all familiar with the Windows operating system found on most computers these days. I actually found the OS to be quite similar in terms of looks and layout to the OS that my old Pocket PC had. I’m sure there’s been a million behind the scenes improvements to the OS since 2002, but it seems visually that Microsoft has taken an evolutionary process with their mobile OS, slapping in more options and icons as they need to in order to address the added device functions and control options offered by the modern generation of Windows Mobile smartphones.

I think you have to approach the Windows Mobile operating system with the right mindset to appreciate it and have patience for it. When I think of it as a ‘mini-laptop’ rather than a ‘communications tool’ I have much more patience with its inefficiencies and annoyances in executing simple tasks. With Microsoft Office Mobile and Windows Media Player native to the device, it very much does resemble a mini-computer running Windows. I’m also finding the OS to be quite slow – I’m often waiting for it to catch up to actions I have performed, and it gets hung up at weird times, which is also something you might expect of a computer running Windows (to be fair, I have both a Dell and a Mac these days and manage to find issues with both!).

When I think about the Tilt as a 'communications tool' and compare it head-to-head with the BlackBerry I pretty much want to throw the Tilt and Windows Mobile out the window (pun most definitely intended). The Windows Mobile OS is not very mobile user friendly compared to the BlackBerry OS. Its user experience is more akin to a computer that’s been downsized into a phone instead of starting with the demands of a mobile user and building an OS around the way a mobile user actually works (yes, that is what RIM has done with the BlackBerry).

There are a lot of old schoolers out there who have zero ability with computers (never used them and never will) who are BlackBerry users. The OS is very quick to learn and become productive with – no previous computer knowledge required. Based on my experiences with the Tilt so far, I guarantee if you gave any of these users a smartphone equipped with Windows Mobile they too would chuck it out the window.

Between the Tilt’s form factor and the Windows Mobile OS the user response actions required from receiving and replying to any sort of message are just too confusing and too slow.  Having to manually power up the device out of standby, navigate into your messages, slide out the keyboard and wait for the screen to rotate, or slide out the stylus… it’s all a brutal experience compared to checking email messages on a BlackBerry which requires… wait for this… pulling the BlackBerry out of the holster and reading the email that will already be present on the screen.

Everybody warned me to get ready for some device lock-ups, but I’m happy to report that I’m now 72 hours into it and the OS hasn’t crashed yet (though I’m pretty sure it’s come close more than few times). Just to compare, I once went eight months on my BlackBerry 8700r without having to turn it off or reboot.

Ending on a positive note, I love all the Windows Mobile Xylophone tones. They do put me in a happy mood and make me more willing to put up with the device. Good Job Microsoft.

Synching to the PC
Easy. I downloaded ActiveSync, installed it, had to reboot my Dell (boooo!), but from there it worked flawlessly to sync my Outlook Calendar, Contacts and Tasks. It was really no different than synching to my BlackBerry via Desktop Manager. Both seem to get the job done well, though as of now I’d have to say ActiveSync is a little bit prettier, but word has it RIM will soon release a prettier Desktop Manager.

Setting up WiFi
This was a little bit strange at first because I initially tried to setup a new WiFi connection while I actually had WiFi turned off in the Wireless Manager screen. Once I found the error in my ways, setting up the WiFi was easy and I connected to my wireless connection and proceeded to download a 3 meg file in seconds. Of course, the first file I downloaded was for BlackBerry Connect.

Setting up Email
When browsing through the Programs and Settings on the Tilt, my heart made a quick jump for joy when I saw the BlackBerry logo. I was wondering how I would fair with getting email setup on the Tilt and thanks to BlackBerry Connect the process was simple. Of course I’m a regular BlackBerry user with an exisiting BlackBerry data plan, so I was able to get Push email on the Tilt with no call required to my carrier. My main email address is Kevin @ CrackBerry.com, which I have forwarded to my Gmail account. I put my Gmail email address and password into the BlackBerry Connect Email Settings page, changed my Reply From address to be Kevin @ CrackBerry.com and that was it. Done. It only took a couple of minutes to experience the joys of push email on a device other than a BlackBerry. I did temporarily experience the problem of having messages sent from the Tilt and/or Gmail appearing in my phone’s inbox again, but was able to get that resolved with some quick help from the CrackBerry.com Forums.

Media Player
As a Windows Mobile phone the Tilt features Windows Media Player. I’m not sure if I would call it good or bad – I guess really I’m indifferent as I’m not a huge listen-to-music-everywhere-I-go kind of guy. The Media Player works and is familiar to use (and does movies!), but it’s based on the PC version and is not exactly user-friendly if for example you wanted to go for a jog and have this be your source of music.

I found it interesting that the Tilt doesn’t have a headset port. I personally don’t mind this as it has A2DP and I’m a Bluetooth guy (typically rock’n the Motorola S9s with my Curve) but I’m sure there are many who would be disappointed with this fact.

Bluetooth Pairing
It took a few more clicks compared to a BlackBerry to pair my Blueant Z9 Bluetooth headset to the Tilt but the process was smooth and stress free.

Voice Dialing
One of my favorite BlackBerry features is Voice Dialing (I use it with either a Bluetooth headset or Bluetooth speakerphone in the car while driving), and the Windows Mobile platform does offer it though the system is different compared to BlackBerry. With BlackBerry Voice Dialing, all of the contacts from the Address Book are available at the Voice Dialing prompt. With the BlackBerry Voice Dialing software you do have to pronounce some names a little bit funny for them to be recognized properly (i.e. speak phonetically) and the system isn’t overly kind to people with thick accents, but on the bright side it requires no set-up.

Windows Mobile takes a different approach by allowing the user to create Voice Tags for contacts. You choose which contact and number you want to create a Voice Tag for, and from there you record the name into the phone by saying it with your own voice. When it comes time to use the Voice Dialing feature the accuracy should be quite high as it’s using your own pronunciation.

I put the Windows Mobile Voice Dialing to the test and was really impressed with the accuracy it returned… 100% It takes a lot more time to setup than the BlackBerry Voice Dialer, but if you use the feature a lot (which I do) it would be worth the upfront investment of time.

I’d love to see RIM add this feature to the BlackBerry so you could experience the best of both worlds. By default (if no Voice Tag is recorded) the standard Voice Dialing software would be used, and if you want to put in the effort you could record personalized Voice Tags to improve the system’s speed and accuracy.

GPS
The Tilt’s GPS package seems incredibly powerful. I downloaded and installed Google Maps and the GPS found me right away with pin point accuracy. I was impressed with how fast the device picked up my location, and I’ve been told there are some tweaks you can do to further improve that speed. I have more testing to see how it stacks up directly to the BlackBerry’s GPS (I’ll have CrackBerry James come for a visit with his 8800 since I’m forbidden to use mine) but from previous BlackBerry GPS experience am thinking the internals HTC is using put the Tilt a step ahead in this department.

Camera
It has video recording. It doesn’t have a flash. And it’s driving me nuts. This will be topic I tackle over the next couple of days in the WMExperts Round Robin forum, but slow, glitchy, not user-friendly, glitchy and slow are all words that describe my experience with the Tilt’s Camera so far.

Battery Life
I wanted to give the Tilt’s battery the benefit of the doubt, but despite its relatively large size the phone hasn’t lasted a full 24 hours for me yet. I expected poor battery life on days 1 and 2 when I was playing with it non-stop, but yesterday I used it as I normally would my BlackBerry, and I had to plug it in by 7:45pm. Even my Curve, which I consider to have poor battery life, will go a couple of days under normal use.

Data Loss
Speaking of batteries, each time the battery level gets low on the Tilt I get several warnings about having to save data or risk it being lost. That never, ever, ever ever happens on a BlackBerry.

Initial Likes/Gripes/Things I Need To Figure Out

After three days of use, here’s how the Windows Mobile Tilt is stacking up with my BlackBerry Curve:

Likes:

  • A lot of features and functions crammed into one device: 3G, WiFi, GPS, Camera
  • It can do some things that off the shelf BlackBerry’s don’t do: Video Recording, Voice Tagging, Create/Edit Word Docs
  • Though I’m not yet a fan of the Tilt’s multitude of input options, having the touchscreen is actually kind of nice. I don’t think I’d ever want a touchscreen to replace the BlackBerry’s keyboard, but being able to tap application shortcuts on the Home Screen and have them open might be kind of fun

Dislikes:

  • Having to turn on the display from standby using the power button. No power on from any button or automatic power on (pulled from holster)
  • Too many control/input options. I can’t figure out the best way to physically hold/use the device
  • Slow/Glitchy OS. Here's just a few occurences:
    • I view emails, read all of them, and close the email window and the Today Screen still shows I have 6 unread messages. 10 seconds later it goes back to saying zero
    • The transition between portrait/landscape is extremely slow
    • Twice the phone has been sitting on my desk in standby, received an email, started vibrating, and not stopped vibrating on its own (several minutes later I pulled out the sliding keyboard and it stopped)
    • The Trackwheel functioning is glitchy – especially in the email app. You can’t easily scroll to where you want the cursor to be. It just jumps around everywhere
    • Touchscreen input becomes unresponsive at random moments (several touches required before input gets recognized)
  • With so much going on with the control options, it’s easy to miss hit keys/buttons/icons and end up some place where you don’t want to be
  • Extremely Poor Battery life (compared to BlackBerry)
  • Two-handed operation pretty much always required - No Thanks!
  • Data Loss a likely possibility with Windows Mobile

Things I Need To Figure Out ASAP:

  • How do I make a button other than the Power button turn the device on out of standby?
  • How do I turn off the blinking LED lights? They are driving me INSANE. The green one is always blinking (yes, I know I’m connected to the network). I searched the device settings inside and out and cannot find the option to turn it off! On the BlackBerry you can get their in three clicks: Options > Screen/Keyboard > LED Coverage Indicator

Conclusion

So that’s where I’m at with Windows Mobile and the AT&T Tilt! I’ve been told there is lot of performance and usability to be had out of the Tilt if you “hack” it. I don’t know what the process is, so if any of the Tilt fans reading this want my final taste of Windows Mobile candy to be sweet I’m going to need some help.

Be sure to come back later this week for my next Smartphone Round Robin post which will cover my final thoughts on Windows Mobile and the AT&T Tilt.

Topics: SPE Round Robin

Reader comments

Smartphone Round Robin: Goodbye BlackBerry, Hello Windows Mobile and the ATT Tilt

46 Comments
Sort by Rating

this looks cool, wonder if its as good as the pocket pc, my co worker keeps boasting about it when i flash my bb pearl

I'm one of the folks who runs 2 devices. A personal phone and a work phone. In this case those devices are an AT&T Tilt(bought the first day it came out to replace my loveable 8525), and a Blackberry 8820.

Let's be real in terms of email, calendar sync, nothing is easier to use than a Blackberry, as u said you don't need to be PC literate to use a Blackberry.

As for the Tilt, yeah its pretty much a small PC. The thing is even without hacking it, there is such a plethora of software available for the WM OS that the device has a huge number of uses. Now only that but its more stable than the previous OS, with the only downers being the long "camera shutter" time, and the removal of the light/flash.

I love both my devices for their uses. The Tilt is a great multimedia devices, I stream music from my home Windows Home Server, I watch Cingular Video, I watch my home TV via Slingbox on it.

It is one of the THE premier Windows OS smartphones. Bar none.

I think one of the hardest things to get used to would be the fact that it takes two hands to use the Tilt. Maybe we are spoiled by the wonder of BlackBerry??

I don't think it gets much simpler than my 8830 Blackberry. I hope Verizon unlocks GPS on the 8th of November. Thank you for the review, but you will need to pry MY Blackberry from my cold, dead fingers (or thumbs).

This is gonna be fun to watch. Most of my friends run PPCs so this royal rumble of smartphones will be fun. Oh, and my fiance has a T-mobile Dash(wm6 smartphone), and I know on it the only way we've found to turn the flashing led off is a third party app. Pretty annoying if you ask me.

I'm interested in all smartphones, and my next device could very well be a blackberry or a symbian device, just so I can experience them all. My company uses only BB, so eventually I'll probably have to switch. Anyways, Windows Mobile is DEFINITELY NOT a simple OS to learn and use. I've been using PPCs since I was in High School, so I know my way around these things. My biggest complaint is probably also Kevin's: the slowdowns. Now I know one big reason is because of how powerful the OS is, and I doubt anyone will disagree with me. However, as a seasoned veteran, I know of ways to make the device snappier. For what it's worth, I think that Kevin might have benefited from using a Treo 750 as it allows for a more seamless integration given the similar form factor. I'm curious about the Blackberry world, so I figure I'll be on these forums more and more. The Curve 8310 has caught my eye...

Yeah... either we are too used to the blackberry or every other cell phone sucks...
I just love my blackberry, is the best thing that has happened to me. I believe that the blackberry is the most user friendly phone and the only phone that is fast and actually gets the job done, while being an easy to use phone.

But it would be nice to have the "freedom" Wm offers, much more apps and stuff available....unless iGO comes out with a BB version...LOL

pry

Im not sold on any phone that has WM 6 is a hit or miss for me. Its too buggy and it gets frustrating like a normal PC. Its the reason why i would get a Mac...everything is simplistic and quick to the gun. The phone looks nice but it reminds me a square version of the Tmobile Wing or a sqaure ver. of a helio ocean. im sure the media is nice but no flash on the camera sucks. The curve is easy to use,quick to learn, and its still customizable..no where near as WM 6 but you still have access to apps which i like. I like WM because of the vast programs it has..but thats about it....

i'd love to get a wm6 phone to try out-- mostly for some of the cool apps that they've got available. however, i'm loving my 8300 and can't imagine upgrading to anything but a blackberry from now on. :)

Like the BlackBerry is what I'm looking for (they have it right):

- one button to put it into sleep mode directly

- basically have any depressed button (all or any i dictate) snap it out of sleep mode

From what I can find out abt mapping a diff standby/sleep button, it has to come from a downloadable program, while the device does support button remapping, out of the box it seemingly will not allow you to remap the power/standby buttons this program (http://ae.inc.ru/aebplus.php)<--this tool is flooded on all the HTC forums, much like how BB messenger is a REQUIRED item for BB .ie..xda-developers.com, htcwiki..etc..etc...offers a 14 day free trial and has what you are looking for..from what I can review anyways, theirs also a KaiserTweak Package that will do this as well, but that all depends on how far you wish to go into the device internals, I dunno what your abilities are with the devices and/or comfort level with shall we say "hacks" to make it work the way you want, personally..some of the hacks look great but to the "average" person may not even be something they would even want to try, yet again another reason why I don't like WINMobile devices, they seem to not work they way YOU want out of the box, requiring possible warrenty voids just to "make" a perfect device.

I haven't been a big fan of the WM-based smartphones, and from this description I can say I still feel that way. One of the reasons why PalmOS, and by the use of same the Treo, has been so successful is because it's very easy to use with little training. RIM learned that lesson and improved upon it with the BlackBerry OS. After all this time, from WinCE 1.0 and onward, Microsoft still hasn't quite gotten it right. They keep trying to cram Windows into a small format, when they should have simply started from scratch.

Sticking with my Pearl, and a possible upgrade to a next gen Curve when my phone contract runs out. Unless, of course, I win one of these contests...

My contracts expired last summer, so I was checking out whether to switch my Treo650 (PalmOS) to either WinMob or BB. I had my Treo 'tricked out' with over $300 in 3rd party apps, most of which I'd be able to transfer to WinMobi.

In the end, my decision was more based on carrier than anything else (if you can't get a connection where you live and work, you have nothing, right?). After having my 8800 less than a day, I knew I'd made the right decision. Out of the box, my 8800 was 'almost' as good as my tricked out Treo had been! (three words for Intuit - Quicken for BB!!!) I was so sure of it that I bought a pearl a 5 weeks later and now have both!

After reading this, I'm even MORE convinced that I made the right decision. I'm BB for life!!!!

*(Intuit - are you listening???? Quicken for BB!!!!!)

I've been a Treo user for 4 years and recently decided to "upgrade" to a HTC S710. I used it for a week and then sent it back. Great screen, great build quality but the sluggishness, WM6 and clunkiness of the sliding keyboard were big dealbreakers. You hit the nail on the head when saying that a bigger keyboard doesn't make for a better input device. I think I'll wait for the 8320 to arrive in the UK and go for that.

i guess it just depends on the things you need you're device to do. the main comment that i have noticed from blackberry users is that once you've had a bb then you don't really want to go back. but it is refreshing to see a report on a device and get another unbiased opinion.

I used Palm Devices ( 1 to 5 ), Handspring, Palm, Blackberry Pearl, and now the HTC Tilt ( 8925 ). So far the Tilt has been more user friendly, and feature-ful than the BB. Neither one has crashed on me, but the Tilt was much easier to set up and use than the BB, and I am saving a lot of cash b/c activesync is working over my normal data plan to access my hosted Exchange server. Tething it only required Activesync software and a USB cable, as Internet sharing is built in the device.

There are too many advantages to list here ( full keyboard, WiFi, mobile Office apps, media player, 3G, etc ) so I'll just say that I went BB, and came back.

I have been debating whether to get a Blackberry or a Windows device in the near future. So far - it sounds like the Blackberry is the way to go. Hopefully the new Pearl 8130 will be available on Verizon soon!!!

Im a huge fan of this project. Im sure that its gotta be difficult switching phones for 3 straight weeks, but Im really interested in seeing all the pros and cons from each device...and we have the best of the best working on it.

This review was exactly what I needed to make the decision to keep my 8310!! I didn't think I could live without WIFI and T-Mobile is being a PITA about me setting up service in a non T-mobile area (Charleston SC) on a 8320 so the Tilt was my next option. I'm still well within my 30 day trial period and up to this point I wasn't convinced that my 8310 was the one for me but this review has sealed it.

Thanks!!

Settings->System->Key Lock

I think Windows Mobile users seem to be more likely to pocket their devices instead of holster them (and unfortunately, good holsters/belt clip cases are not yet available for the Tilt since it is too new, unlike the Boxwave Active Case I had for my 8525 and loved), which is why the default is relatively cautions in terms of the ability to bring the device out of sleep.

I tried disabling the key lock once and found that it was basically impossible to pocket the phone.

Also, http://forum.xda-developers.com/ is an excellent resource for users of HTC devices.

Speaking of default behaviors, a lot of the defaults in the current Kaiser ROMs (both the HTC TyTn II and the Tilt) are admittedly rather annoying and nonsensical. Someone else mentioned a "must have" utility for Windows Mobile I don't have myself, but if you have an HTC Kaiser (TyTn II, Tilt, or one of the European carrier-branded Kaiser variants), you need KaiserTweak. Go to the aforementioned forums, choose the "Kaiser" section, and KaiserTweak has a sticky thread there.

I started using PDA's and the like many moons ago. Still owning the Palm 5000, then a Cassieopia, then back to Handspring, then an HP Ipaq(to me still the best device sans a phone) onto an XV6600(hacked), XV6700(hacked extensively) and now to a BB 8830.

After all those years with a Windows mobile device and touch screen, stylus etc, I have to say my biggest grip and still is. No one input method is superior over the the other forcing you to use multiple input methods reducing the effectiveness of a one handed device. While the for the power user a Windows mobile device has its advantages, I firmly believe BB/RIM got it right and are making the necessary adjustments here and there as users become more vocal, all this without a complete OS overhaul such as Window Pocket PC, to Mobile, etc.

Blackberry is my choice and I don't see that changing anytime soon. I guess you can say its almost full circle the easier the OS the better the user experience, better over all performance and better mobility.

Just my 2 cents!

I am loving this idea....Can't wait to see the review of the Palm Treo...I considered myself a dyed in the wool Palm girl (still have my Tungsten E), and the only reason I didn't get a Treo was that I could not find one with a decent price.

Thank you Kevin, for "taking one for the team" LOL

Excellent write-up. I think this round robin is awesome. I've gone through several Winblowz mobile devices and LOVE my new 8310 more after reading the first installment. For a road warrior like me, battery life and email reign supreme. I laugh over the Brick(R) not getting through an entire day and that was all too painfully common with my Treo 700wx on VZW. 8310 on AT&T? Wail on email all day, an hour or so of voice and throw in a couple of GPS routes and some light surfing for good measure. I find myself looking at the phone back in the hotel room that night thinking "OMG - do I even need to recharge?". Plus, my BB is ready to rock in 2 hours max. T700wx (with an 1800 mAh battery no less) took 4-5 hours to fully recharge a dead battery. For the 'business user' profile I fit, I'm in love with my new favorite phone of all time. And no, it's not anything from MS.....

This was an interesting review. I just wanted to address some of your concerns:

1. To power on the device besides using the power button, just goto Start\Settings\System and in there, you will find a "Key Lock" icon. Click on that and it will give you the option to power on the device with any key. Just pick "Do Not Lock Buttons".

2. Most of what I do on the device is by voice recognition. And no, I don't use the Voice Speed Dial that comes with it. I purchased Microsoft Voice Command 1.6. This is true voice recognition. I can just say "Dial 555-555-5555" through my Jawbone headset and the phone will dial. Or I can say "Call Dad at work" and it will pull from my contacts list. Also, with Voice Command, it will speak out all new email headers to me, announce calendar reminders, and announce who is calling me, either by name or number. You can also start applications or find contacts through the voice command.

3. I have changed my device's Today screen so that a lot of my interaction with device is through the touchscreen with larger icons.

4. Because of the flexibility with the Windows Mobile platform, I have installed my SlingBox on the device, my own GPS application I purchased, instead of using the subscription based TeleNav service, a business card reader application that uses the built-in camera to scan cards and put them into your contact list, Windows Live Messenger to chat (since all of my friends use this), and a different media player that I installed. Lastly, I have installed a BT application that routes all audio to a mono BT Headset if I wanted.

5. I personally have not experienced any of the glitches you have seen, but I won't say it can't happen.

6. Data loss is not a possiblity really with WM6 as it usees non-volatile ROM to store your information. So if the battery dies out, it won't lose your information like older Windows Mobile 2002/2003.

7. The poor battery life is also a function of using 3G data connections. It is widely accepted that UMTS/HSDPA eats up more battery life. I have downloaded an application that allows me to turn of the HSDPA and keep it on EDGE if I wanted to keep my Battery life up.

While I admit that the Blackberry platform is simpler to use, I think for power users, the Tilt is an equally great device.

One other comment:

For whatever reason, it seems that in the first week of most HTC devices' lives, the charging circuitry "learns" about the device. I've heard a lot of people indicate that even with 3G enabled, battery life improves significantly after the first week of use.

I don't live in a 3G service area, so I've never had bad battery life to begin with.

The new Blackberries with 3G capability will probably experience the same battery life reduction issues...

I'll agree to that. My battery life has been pretty good so far. I'll go a whole day making some phone calls, checking emails, a little Internet and music listening and I'll be down to about 60%-70%

I have a short question. Is this phone locked by ATT? And if yes, if you flash the ROM with HTC one will you be able to use it with SIM cards from other operators?
Thank you for helping.

Yes, if you do re-flash the Tilt with an HTC ROM, you can also do a CID Unlock and use other carrier SIM cards in it.

Not correct.

CID lock and SIM lock are completely different things.

CID lock prevents you from flashing other carrier's ROMs onto the device. Thus flashing the HTC ROM won't let you CID-unlock the phone, as CID-unlocking has to be done in order to permit flashing the HTC ROM in the first place! That said, CID-unlocking by installing HardSPL is easy.

There is no SIM unlocker for the Kaiser yet. It's pretty easy to get an unlock code from AT&T if you're a customer in good standing though.

I wonder if you'd find a different hardware form-factor would leave you with a different impression. For example, the TMobile Shadow is designed for 1-handed operation, and features a shure-type keyboard similar to the Pearl.

Great review. I looked this phone over at the AT&T store. I like the feel and look of this phone, but I would have a hard time giving up my Curve. I am glad to see the voice recognition program works well. Does it work better than the voice dialing feature of the Curve? I use it everyday and it is the best of all voice dialing. Thanks for the comprehensive look of this phone.

HairBear

I had the Curve - LOVED IT - but needed a smart phone my old PDA went belly up. To answer your question - NO this is not as easy as the voice dialing from the Curve. You have to go through menus to get to it. This defeats the purpose of having voice dialing. It's driving me nuts! Hoping they come out with a fix very soon

I have to debunk that one. I have the tilt. I also use a bluetooth headset. I hit the button on my headset, voice dial starts automatically, I say the number to dial and it does it. I never even need to touch the phone! Try it.

Great review....but at 1st glance, I can tell i like the BB better. to much to move around/open.

Thanks for the eval. I thought getting the blackjack for my daughter (she originally wanted that slide out keyboard) may have been a mistake but your assessment convinced me that it was the right decision.

I received mine on monday, and found I am having similar likes dislikes, one thing I have done is put the phone permanently in landscape mode to avoid the delay/lag when i slide the keyboard in and out.