Round Robin: TheiPhoneBlog's Final Thoughts on the Bold!
Posted in SPE Round Robin on 22 Dec 2008 09:58 by Kevin Michaluk | 153 comments


[ This is an official Smartphone Round Robin post! Every day you reply to an official Round Robin blog post or forum thread on CrackBerry.com, you automatically gain an entry ballot for a chance to win a BlackBerry Bold, Spare Bold Battery, and Case Mate Second Skin! ] 

Payback time! Over at The iPhone Blog, editor Rene Ritchie has followed up his initial impressions video (which you can watch above) with his full-out BlackBerry Bold review. How did he fair? You're going to have to jump over to TiPb to read it, but let me set the tone with a quote from his introduction paragraph...

...I loved it and hated it. How utterly appropriate. Not to be too tale of two-cities about it, but it was both the best of the Round Robin devices for me and the worst. 

Rene even took the CrackBerry Kevin philosophical approach during his review and examined the BlackBerry Way of Life (which scares him!). Agree or disagree, Rene's review is definitely worth reading. Even I think some of his points are right on the money. Don't forget to drop a comment there for your chance to win an iPhone 3G or here for a Bold (you can do both!).

Leave your comment Send to a friend

Comments
By: Pachelbel | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 14:47

screen shots really show the advantage of having such a large Screen

By: Unkle Grouch (not verified) | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 14:48

Even iPhone loyalists are impressed with the Bold. That says a lot.

By: ElDudeorino | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 10:07

bold rules!

By: tcmahoang | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 10:11

Looks like there is some blackberry love coming from a true-blue iPhone user (:

By: Doug Proctor (not verified) | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 14:55

Have just got the Bold and what an incredible phone. Thought the 8320 was a good phone but the Bold blows this away. Apart from the touch interface, is there that much difference?

By: rrrebo | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 15:07

What can you say? You really just can't compare Apples and...BlackBerries! Two completely different fruits that suit different tastes.

By: nighguy@hotmail.com (not verified) | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 10:28

Interesting perspective but bb users have control over just how much gets pushed to the phone and what we want to be alerted for. So for the most part I can adjust my bb experience to the degree of "crack ness" I want. I appreciate having that level of control to dial in the intensity I want or need. So if I wanted to be laid back bb user, I could be.

By: Dimietriev | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 15:24

I saw it as he liked it, but Rene is just a different kind of smartphone user.

By: mkoby | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 15:25

I'm glad that the reviews for the Bold are favorable. Everyone can find something wrong with any phone given a few minutes. So the fact that people have a few issues with the Bold is no big surprise. I'm just glad that the issues people find are small and most say they can live with them.

By: R1cowl | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 15:27

I do like that he did't rehash all that was already said. An original view point. I can't wait to get my own BOLD

By: Brett Jackson (not verified) | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 10:43

I own the blackberry bold and it is a very very nice phone. I have owned the blackberry curve 8310 for over a year and this bold is faster, more clear, and easier to use.

I researched the iphone and the bold a lot before making my purchase, the iphone is just too tready for me. I wanted the iphone simply because of all the hype about it. I started researching this phone and found out that it did not do many of the basic functions that I need in a phone ie no picture messaging and no copy/paste functions. Also read that you have to use multiple pages on the keyboard to put a PERIOD at the end of a sentence. I am infamous for using "..." at the end of my sentences when i type text messages so hitting alternate screens 6 times to put 3 periods down was just another annoying thing about the iphone. Lastly I realized I wouldn't get to use my corportate discount (some companies have corporate accounts with AT&T) I work for a company that gets a 20% discount on my bill each month, by adding the iphone, that discount goes away, and my internet bill goes up from $30.00 (blackberry internet) to $45 (iphone internet charge).

SO hands down the blackberry bold won me over. It has the best screen resolution that I have ever seen on a phone to this day. It responds very fast to opening applications, it streams videos like "the office" and "espn". The espn streaming is not as cool as the Verizon deal, but i do get to watch highlights and other things on there. The 3G internet is blazing fast. EDGE is like dialup, 3G is like DSL. I can't wait for the next generation of the phone internet speeds, they will be unreal. I also downloaded the google maps program on this phone which uses the gps on the phone to map your location to your destination. That is amazing as well. I enjoy using my GPS basically for free, without subscribing to AT&T's gps package. The directions on text and not spoken like the at&t version, but for $5.99 per month, i can read.

By: ashworth | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 15:31

I love the bold!

By: ashworth | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 15:31

I love the bold!

By: Sir Twilight King (not verified) | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 15:33

Nice round up. I agree that the any Blackberry browser is still not as good as the iPhone's, but the Blackberry Bold still crushes the iPhone.

By: cancundan | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 10:51

It all comes down to your needs for a smartphone. I think that is the point of the Round Robin overall. There are lots of options.....although I can't imagine what you would be looking for that would make you get the Fuze.....terrible device.

I know people who carry both a Bold and an iPhone. They love the iPhone, but need a good busines/e-mail device. So they use both.

By: Doug H. (not verified) | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 15:44

Well we're gonna have a party
but we'd better put a guard outside...

If the folks come home
I'm afraid they're gonna have my hide!

There'll be no more movies for a week or two
no more hangin' round with the usual crew...

My-ma-my c'mon everybody!

By: aragon7 | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 11:11

Forget the hate part. Everyone loves the Bold

By: jrtplaya21 | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 11:13

Gotta love the bold

By: Anonymous (not verified) | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 16:07

It looks like he liked the Bold a lot, but it was not the right phone for his style of use. Just as you mentioned your perspective on the Storm two podcasts ago,the best phone is one that fits how you would use the phone.

By: JFTeran | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 16:10

True iPhone user trying to find anything negative to point out... its annoying... "Also, while I’m no BlackBerry ninja, I couldn’t find a way to quickly lock the device in the manner of the iPhone sleep/wake button. I could hold down the red phone button, but that seemed to actually turn the services off." How about you hold the mute button down and put it on standby? Is that not quick enough? His review sounded like someone who used the Bold for about an hour without reading a manual...

By: laurenmac | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 11:32

I never get tired of seeing the Bold on video... :sigh:

By: vinndy | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 16:22

I think he is just a little too sold on the iphone. BB is a way of doing things that makes your (my) life a lot easier. Other devices haven't streamlined the way of doing this quite as good as RIM and think that makes the non-users just a little bit uneasy...Happy Holidays to All!

By: PanaSama | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 11:35

Good review but he clearly doesnt get the Crack and i think he completely missed the "on the go" philosophy, sure you could stop and start replying every single message that arrives on your Berry but thats not the point the beauty of it is that you dont have to, whitin a glimpse you could realize if a messege is important or not to reply to and that saves tons of time, people made the same argument when cellphones became popular "oh i dont want to be called everywhere i go, i need privacy!" it all comes down on how productive you want to be.

By: deRusett | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 16:27

I love my Curve, and Would LOVE a Bold or Storm for the better screen, Being a 2 phone yeilder I'd take the Curve/Storm Combo over the Curve/iPhone combo, mind you I am an Always on type of personality,

I really like the way the review put it to the personality and life style over the form and function, the form and function debate has been pounded, YAA Bold has kick ass screen, and iPhone has multi touch, but why pick one over the other, and it is that desire for ALWAYS ON, that makes me a crackberry addict, I turn off audio notifications, so I only have the little red light blinking through my otter box at me, but even with out the light, I pick it up just to know I can message someone, or send and e-mail or surf a website.

The Review Pointed out a few things that are easily changed by the user.
The Annoying Voice Dail button, and Lack of Quick Lock are fixed with 1 item, re-asign the Voice Dial button with Keyboard Lock and you've solved both problems.

The Constant Pinging, Turn Audio Notifications off.

Being "Always ON" Set the Phone to Auto Off and Auto ON when you are not "on the job"

All in All it was a great review, far better than I expected from a Mac Fan boy. Usually they are very biased and singular minded, I guess Mac users have evolved in the last few years.

By: Runell A | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 11:45

Other than Kevin's reviews... I truly enjoyed watching that video and reading Rene's final impression. Rene touched on a lot of my own gripes about owning a BB (24hour availability), but being a more experienced BB user, I know how to turn off and limit my availability when I leave the office doors.

Very well put and hat's off to Rene *applaud*

By: Runell A | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 16:32

Other than Kevin's reviews... I truly enjoyed watching that video and reading Rene's final impression. Rene touched on a lot of my own gripes about owning a BB (24hour availability), but being a more experienced BB user, I know how to turn off and limit my availability when I leave the office doors.

Very well put and hat's off to Rene *applaud*

By: chad.strunk | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 11:55

...it's just a completely different way of doing things.

As for the "crack" aspect, just change the profile to "Phone Only" and answer the messages on your own terms.

By: geek | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 16:49

Do not be scared of the crackberry. embrace it. Love it. and it will love you back

By: dagda1 | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 16:49

Sorry the CrackBerry life scares you but the Bold is where it is at. I need mine. Thanks.

By: skynny70 | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 17:06

I wish a hybrid of the two would be created. I prefer the iPhone for games, Internet browsing (Safari), and general entertainment uses. I much prefer a BlackBerry for email, SMS, etc or business uses. Basically I can communicate better with the BB and its keyboard.

By: Stang68 | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 17:06

for my Dad! He doesn't want a touchscreen like the Storm, so the Bold is his best choice! Pick me, Kevin! :)

By: Cynaburst | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 17:15

There just does not seem to be one device that will make everyone happy. They all have strengths and weaknesses.

By: alonesoul | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 12:34

It's a matter of function. If you need an iPod, then the iPhone is great. If you need a smart phone, then Bold all the way!!!!!

By: DerekO (not verified) | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 17:30

Great review but sounds a bit biased towards your love for the Iphone. All in all great phone and looking forwards to the full review.

By: isaacleese | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 17:32

I really think Kevin's right on the money here - it comes down to usage philosophy. RIM has adopted the utilitarian "add an hour to your day" approach, and Apple has taken the aesthetically pleasing "Apple Experience" philosophy.

By: YaBoyBlu | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 12:45

Great review can't wait for the full review.

By: Anonymous (not verified) | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 17:39

Thanks to all of you for doing this. They insights have been interesting. Some were even useful.

Cheers

By: esperz | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 17:44

BlackBerry and iPhone cannot really be compared because they are so different in many ways and are both offering differents features for differents smartphones users.

Great review.

By: manttium | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 17:55

I thought his review was on the money on a lot of aspects. However, push notification is a compelling feature when coupled with the ability to turn it on or off. At least you have the option of using it if you need to/want to!

By: vupkp44 | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 17:58

A Bold would be a magnificent thing to have under the tree!

By: thegooz | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 13:15

I liked the review.

By: Queen4111 | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 18:06

Secretly, the iPhone guy converted! :)

By: talljason | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 18:13

This was a great review of the Bold from an iPhone user's view. The comparison pictures were really good as well.

By: Storm_Victim | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 13:28

The review was alright. It just sounds like he can't handle the life style of a busy professional. Oh well, it takes all kinds.

By: cashboi68 | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 13:38

it was an alrite review...people who dont come from our world dont appreciate the bigger things that blackberry give us....blackberry 4 lyfe!!!!!

By: ingrassia | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 18:35

It is what it is!!!! BOLD for me PLEASE!!!!!

By: jrogers8 | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 13:48

Still take the Bold over the iPhone, despite the review.

By: chakejaam | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 18:42

bold rocks!

By: a_elyse | Date: Mon, 12/29/2008 - 12:04

i agree :)

By: SparklyShiny | Date: Mon, 12/22/2008 - 13:53

I've enjoyed reading all of the Round Robin reviews, especially because I'm new to the "smartphone" world. It's interesting to see individual preferences and comparisons - and I hope that developers and manufacturers will pay attention to consumers' favorite features when planning new devices. I can't wait to see what the next generation of devices will bring.

I'm thoroughly enjoying my Bold, and the amazing resources available from the CrackBerry community. I'm glad I waited for its release!

Now all I have to do is move my family and friends into CrackBerryLand . . . .

 
 1. 07 Nov 2009 - iluvmybb contest - Music Focused Video Shout Outs!
 2. 07 Nov 2009 - Gym Technik NextGen App for BlackBerry Is Here!
 3. 06 Nov 2009 - Do You Wish the New BlackBerry Bold 9700 Was Bigger? Like Say the Same Size as the Original Bold??
 4. 06 Nov 2009 - CrackBerry Coverage Goes to San Francisco Next Week for the Second Annual BlackBerry Developer Conference!
 5. 06 Nov 2009 - And the Winner in the I Love My BlackBerry Video Contest Is....
 6. 06 Nov 2009 - Remote DVR Access Now Available on BlackBerry Smartphones for Optimum Online and iO Customers
 7. 06 Nov 2009 - Where and Traffic.com Bumper to Bumper Best Bumper Sticker Slogan Contest Winner Announced!
 8. 06 Nov 2009 - CrackBerry Contest: Win an Unlocked T-Mobile BlackBerry Bold 9700 From BlackBerry Emporium And CrackBerry!
 9. 06 Nov 2009 - RoaderRunnerGPS - Analyze Your Walking or Running Workout with your BlackBerry Smartphone
 10. 06 Nov 2009 - Leaked: OS 5.0.0.344 for the BlackBerry Bold 9700!