Join Our 3 MILLION+ Members Today! Register Here | Login
Login or Register to post comments

18 Comments

Posted by alex1 Thursday, Jul 31, 2008 1393 days ago

I love this battery door, the cut out for the speaker is the best part. One thing that I DON'T like is that I also purchased the seidio rubberized case and it does not work well with the battery cover. Why would seidio make the battery cover w/ the awesome speaker holes and then not have the case w/ the same holes? Very poor design. However, that's more a fault of the case then the battery door, so.... on it's own merit the battery door is great.

 
 
Posted by BamaSteve Thursday, Jul 31, 2008 1393 days ago

I think i might have to pick this bad boy up.

 
 
Posted by stewdaddy Thursday, Jul 31, 2008 1393 days ago

First accessory I bought for my Curve and the best.
It looks and feels great, keeps it from sliding around and the speaker works better than with the stock battery cover.

I highly recomend it.

 
 
Posted by svtpickemup Thursday, Jul 31, 2008 1393 days ago

I love the looks and feel of this battery door. Its the way RIM should have built the Curve.

However, the circular mirror lasted about three weeks before the reflective surface rubbed off to reveal a copper colored plastic with no reflective properties at all.

If the disc were recessed instead of sticking out, it would be fine.

Its not that I use the mirror that much, it just looks ghetto now...LOL

 
 
Posted by longshot Thursday, Jul 31, 2008 1393 days ago

1) so its a mirror, I didn't know that ! The mirror's plating wore off quickly so it now looks like a copper disc

2) you can drill a small hole for a lanyard near the top center - or even better - offset so you can carry the BB in a shirt pocket. I like the flash-drive types w/ a string and plastic quick-release latch. If you drill the original cover, you may get a charge at trade-in/up grade.

3) I give it 5.0

 
 
Posted by cheezist Thursday, Jul 31, 2008 1393 days ago

This is a perfect fit for my curve, ht feels great in my hand, gives it better grip, gives it a sort of different look. But I will reiterate what was said above, the chrome looking "mirror" rubbed off after a few weeks, as did the "SEIDO" logo at the bottom, which isn't a bit deal.

 
 
Posted by timlutz Thursday, Jul 31, 2008 1393 days ago

For me this didn't get the job done,not only did the mirror crap out so did the rubber coating!Also I have the clear case and the rubberized back door would not allow the the case to fully close,it's ok but not a buy!

 
 
Posted by Anonymous Thursday, Jul 31, 2008 1393 days ago

I purchased this product for my Curve for better sound quality and received exactly that. Unfortunately I have noticed the battery door to come loose fairly easily. Is anyone else experiencing this problem or is it just me?

 
 
Posted by mbarcus Thursday, Jul 31, 2008 1393 days ago

Had this battery door for a couple months. I have the same issue with the mirror reflection rubbing off....but no big deal because I don't use it. However, be careful when removing/replacing the battery door. One of the little clips that holds the door to the Blackberry has weakened (not broken off yet), so now my door flexes...very irritating.

 
 
Posted by kelvinlin Thursday, Jul 31, 2008 1393 days ago

sorry to scrutinize, but i feel like these review ratings are almost entirely arbitrary... this product has better sound quality, indeed as good as the curve is going to get so why does it only receive a 4 for sound quality? and if the mirror protrudes and is noted as a flaw, then why is "design and function" rated 5 when there is a noted flaw?

 
 
Posted by Gary Mazo Friday, Aug 01, 2008 1392 days ago

Kelvinlin,

Reviews are always subjective - the is the nature of someone looking at something, testing and giving it their opinion. I do think that "arbitrary" is a bit unfair. I and the other reviewers here spend lots of time with the things we review - we compare them to other products and give our best opinions given what is out there in the industry and our own experience. You can certainly disagree - but please don't say it is arbitrary, because it isn't.

Also, "Sound Quality" should read "Fit and Finish" - not sure what happened there - and then I think that would make more sense for you.

 
 
Posted by Adam Zeis Friday, Aug 01, 2008 1392 days ago

I dig this item .. I've had it since I got my 8330 and I love it. Makes it feel so much better and I'm not worried about it scratching. I, like others, wasn't a big fan of the mirror at all, so I removed it and haven't thought about it since. It isn't held on very well regardless - and it stood out and was just bad for the design IMO.

 
 
Posted by j.p.hatfield Saturday, Aug 02, 2008 1392 days ago

Will there be a Pearl cover released??

 
 
Posted by Adam Zeis Saturday, Aug 02, 2008 1391 days ago

I would assume no since the Pearl doesn't have the rubber-ish black sides like the Curve does. This is intended more for the 8330 (I believe) since it flows with the device, so I would doubt on seeing one for the Pearl anytime.

 
 
Posted by j.p.hatfield Sunday, Aug 03, 2008 1391 days ago

though it would be a great "non-slick" cover for a Pearl??

 
 
Posted by Jester23 Saturday, Aug 02, 2008 1391 days ago

I bought this and then 2 days later got an otterbox so I took this off and it's sitting in a drawer incase I decide to take my curve out of the otterbox use it some day. looks great on and feels nice.

 
 
Posted by kingsario Saturday, Aug 02, 2008 1391 days ago

Just bought it...can't wait.

 
 
Posted by The Law Monday, Aug 04, 2008 1389 days ago

My phone fell from a park bench, which is probably a 18 inches or so. The cover popped off and I ended up with scratches on the bottom of the front of the device. Unfortunately all of these "pop" cases seem to have the same protection problem and that this will happen, limiting protection to shock damage and not scratching. I was lucky to cover my screen with plastic and it was relatively unharmed. The only way to truly protect the device completely seems to be with skin cases which absorb perhaps slightly less shock but stay on the device.