Join Our 3 MILLION+ Members Today! Register Here | Login
Login or Register to post comments

50 Comments

Posted by Kevin Michaluk Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Kevin (aka Ryan Seacrest): Wow Joseph. I think it's safe to say you've started Round 1 with the bar raised pretty high here. Let's see what the judging panel has to say.

CrackBerry Idol Judges

Dieter: Love the video! Hilarious start but you really hit the main features really well, it's easy to follow and just the right length. On the review side, glad to see you try to provide some information about podcasts at the beginning, but yo dog, citing Wikipedia in your
first paragraph is so 2004. Tighten that up and talk a bit more about actually using the app to listen to podcasts and you'd have a real winner here. Lot of potential, I definitely hope you make the next round.(and yes, I think I'll be putting 'yo dog' in every post. *sighs*)

Georgia: Nice work there Joseph. The creativity you've shown in both your audition video and now your app review video are first rate. I can't help but wonder if you will be able to keep these ideas flowing non-stop. I sure hope so. The review itself was well written and broken down logically. You definitely seem cracky enough to be a regular here, so hopefully you can show us some more brilliance in your next round if you make it through. One thing I wouldn't have minded seeing a bit more on is the alternatives available to Podtrapper. Are there any? Are they better or worse?

Craig: Great video! Loved the beginning. He sounds like he is a VO artist. Great review. Covered the important points, showed the app. The blog post is well written, and again covers the things I am interested in. I hope we see Joseph in the next round.

 
 
Posted by shankeith Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Lol @ "yo dawg"

Good review btw Joseph

 
 
Posted by Adam Zeis Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

I love your video style ... it's awesome.

 
 
Posted by gavreh Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Podtrapper is an amazing application - one of the few I use constantly and have happily paid for.

 
 
Posted by DJ Reyes Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Great review Joseph. Getting nervous now. This competition is really heating up. It's exciting. I must say that video was awesome.

Best of luck.

 
 
Posted by that_maynard Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

It will be interesting to see how everyone else does, that was pretty good.

 
 
Posted by that_maynard Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

It will be interesting to see how everyone else does, that was pretty good.

 
 
Posted by copster30 Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

One of the best feature of Podtrapper is that it will never ever lose your playing position. This happens way to frequently on other music apps and is a nightmare if you're listening to anything over 1 hour.

 
 
Posted by collin16 Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Nice review. For those of you not willing to pay for the full app you can download the limited Crackberry version! Its free and great

appworld.blackberry.com/webstore/content/6589

 
 
Posted by bighap Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Very well done.

 
 
Posted by ldcmobile Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Really well put together

 
 
Posted by R1cE Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

good review. I wasnt a fan of the intro to be honest. Found it too cliche and reminds me of the humor found on Disney Channel. Some people like it, some don't so keep that in mind.

 
 
Posted by tes5884 Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Gr8 review!!!

 
 
Posted by sweetlittlehugs Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

I disagree about there being no room for improvement. The playlists are clunky to use, as there is no other way to advance to the next podcast without picking up my phone I find myself only choosing long podcasts.

 
 
Posted by 3Dee Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

A nice app to choose to review and you rep'd it pretty well. Read a bit like a college essage for my liking though (we all know what podcasts are and agree with Dieter - don't quote wikipedia). Pretty good though.

 
 
Posted by bluegreen1965 Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Joseph has a terrific presence on, and behind, the camera. He's my fave!

 
 
Posted by bgriff25 Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

I thouhgt Joseph did a great job. He's got my vote.

 
 
Posted by Zanshin- Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Hey Joseph! Zander here, just wanted to show some support and say awesome job on your app review. Very through and well thought out!

 
 
Posted by pkcable Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Nice review Joseph! I agree podtrapper is a great app. :)

 
 
Posted by mahen915 Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

That was a great review. By any chance, does anyone what theme that is that's displayed in the screenshots? I want it :)

 
 
Posted by shankeith Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

The crackberry theme

 
 
Posted by Joseph Holder Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

It's the Berry Holiday (http://crackberry.com/free-cb2-blackberry-theme) theme, CrackBerry style. The wallpaper is CrackBerry infused, too (http://crackberry.com/wallpaper-colors-patterns-mod-abstract) I love this free theme!

 
 
Posted by BBNewbie2010 Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

In the beginning of the video, it was kind of like a cheezy informercial.....I chuckled a bit...... I like to say that the review both from the video and review blog was short and to the point, one thing that was missing and the cool thing about Podtrapper is that when you are listening to a podcast and you get an incoming call or text message, podtrapper pauses and when you finish the call or ending the text message, the podcast resumes.

I have this app and it's one of the most used app I go to evevery day.

 
 
Posted by Sashko Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

I must say, you are most definitely a worthy opponent in this contest, and I tip my hat to you :-) Hope to meet you in the next round.

Alex

 
 
Posted by trjnberry Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Good review of a great app. As I recently indicated in a forum conversation, if you are not into podcasts, you will be with an app like Podtrapper. I would have liked to have seen the video review be more of a review of the app and less of a commercial. As a daily CB blog reader, I don't feel that you need to sell me on the app. I think you need to let the reader draw their own conclusion based on your objective review of the product. Podtrapper is a comprehensive app. I think if you do video reviews, you don't want to skip over menus. Spend less time on the commerical and fit those menus in.

As a Podtrapper user, I can say that you can use Itunes to shop for your podcasts, then get a name of a podcast you want, and then you can use the Podtrapper search menu by that podcast name and generally it comes up. Of course, like your review indicated, you can also just note the feed URL and enter it manually in the Podtrapper menu. A fellow podtrapper user from the forums said he could read audio books via podtrapper; would've been nice if your review could have touched upon how to do that.

I am a CB user at large. No affiliation with any CB Idol contestant. I am looking forward to providing objective feedback where I can. I wish you best of luck in your CB Idol journey.

 
 
Posted by CrackCurve56 Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

I have one thing to say to Joseph, and this is constructive criticism. The one thing is: YAWN.

 
 
Posted by TheElderBerry Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

How many of these do you expect people to sit through? I don't know guys, this is kind of weak.

 
 
Posted by Joseph Holder Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Great comments from everybody. I'd like to respond to some of them, and rather than clicking that reply link a whole lot of times, I'll respond to them here.

Dieter: I was going to use the standard "Webster's Dictionary Defines..." bit, but I thought that was too 1980's. Ah, well.

Georgia: I had some links in there for some other podcatching apps, but I think they got lost along the way.

Craig: I'm not a voice over artist, but I'd *love* to be one. *wink, wink, nudge, nudge* to any Charlotte-area producers out there.

3Dee: Ever try explaining podcasts to your mom? I wanted to make sure I was on a firm ground with my readers.

Zander & Sashko: Class, pure class :) EDIT (oops): And shankeith, too

BBNewbie2010: I was trying to keep the video and blog to a certain length. I'd need to write a novel to list all the cool things PodTrapper does!

trjnberry: Excellent constructive criticism. It's my first time making a review video, so your advice is certainly appreciated. I really do love PodTrapper and was very pleased when I got the go-ahead to do a review on it.

CrackCurve56: You left of the bit where you tell me why you found the article to be "YAWN?" I always find that my work only improves with the feedback of others. Please share.

To everybody else, thank you for your comments. I, like most of you, can't wait to see what else CrackBerry Idol has in store for us. Good luck, fellow idol-ers!

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

This is a pretty good review, except that your video and voice overs made it all seem too much like a personal "vote for me" infomercial. I guess that's to be expected, maybe.

I, too, use Podtrapper pretty much daily and love the app. You're correct in that it takes the headaches out of downloading and not losing place in a recording. I even listen to audio books (broken down by chapter) through this app.

Again, great start!

 
 
Posted by compinche Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Loved the video and want to wish you luck in the crackberry-idol! Wish I could give you more than two thumbs up, but only have two hands! Great job! You got my vote!

 
 
Posted by shacknews Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

THIS IS FOR THE NEXT CONTESTANTS:

Do a good job or you GTFO now.

 
 
Posted by grayzweb Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Great work! Really loved the video!

 
 
Posted by Bold_until_Hybrid_Comes Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

ON TO THE NEXT ONE

 
 
Posted by Cap_172R Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

Great video.. nice style!! other contestants will have to step it up! good job!

 
 
Posted by dterio Monday, Jun 28, 2010 696 days ago

i love the intro!! Great job!!

 
 
Posted by shv580 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Great Job Joseph! Nice video intro too! Lol...
By the way: Nice theme you got there, what is it called?

 
 
Posted by Revyrah Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

You hit a bases clearing triple, in my opinion. The homer will come, I'm sure.

The video presence was great, and the writing was only a hair behind the aforementioned. The only critique one can really have is to check for typos three times before submitting for publishing. Otherwise you'll hear the constant harassment that Bla1ze does for errors. No matter how good the overall presentation.

You really did a great job and I highly doubt you'll have much trouble progressing through the next rounds. You're very eloquent, informed, and your experience in this type of field, as well as the knowledge of the blackberry stands out. You've got an early lead Joseph. Keep this up and you won't have to look back.

 
 
Posted by Propa Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

i knew from the audition vid that Joseph would do great and he has proven me right...nice vid, great speaking voice, really good review....thumbs up

 
 
Posted by Xopher Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

The video was good (a little dark at the beginning - either need better lighting when not showing the BB screen, or shoot with a background instead of into a darkened space behind you).

The article was very good, and informative. There were highlights in the article that showed more features than I have seen in other PodTrapper reviews, so that was really good.

 
 
Posted by AgentScribe Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

You did a great job Joseph. Much more professional than the resident bloggers here and I don't mean that to slam them but just to complement your abilities in this realm. I agree with Georgia and hope this is something you can keep up.

 
 
Posted by Terrigno Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

This guys got good humor. I like to see that in people. Its always good to watch a review with a little humor in it. Way to go.

 
 
Posted by hingham55 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

Podtrapper works so well and I enjoy it more than any other BB application. Buy this five star application today and you will enjoy thousands of hours of entertainment.

 
 
Posted by SandyT37137 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

This is one product I happily paid for. I use it daily. I have not however ever used it for a podcast. I stumbled onto this product as a way to listen to audio books that I download free from the public library. What sold me was the ability to use my cheap (non-stereo) bluetooth with this product. I can actually listen to any MP3 file thru my bluetooth.

I would like to see the upgrade suggested by someone else above that would allow the player to immediately start the next file in line once the current file was complete.

And one last thought as I head to the pool, bluetooth in my ear and my phone on safe dry land: can anyone suggest how to go about finding podcast that 50 year old mothers would enjoy.

 
 
Posted by JRF_8520 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 696 days ago

I think you did a great job! The intro was ok, I guess I've seen too many infomercials like that. But still, kept my attention! Good job and hope to see you in the next round!

 
 
Posted by Spiral_ouT Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 695 days ago

Awesome review man. You kept me interested and listening about a product I have no interest in. Hope to see YOU in round 2 of CB idol.

 
 
Posted by bluegreen1965 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 695 days ago

Wow, I can't say it enough...Joseph rocks!!

 
 
Posted by dac035 Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 695 days ago

Good review. The video was creative and the article is well written.

 
 
Posted by LOZ Girl Tuesday, Jun 29, 2010 695 days ago

during infomercials...there usually pretty cheesy. I had higher hopes from you. I enjoy your voice and would have rather had just your hands showing how the app worked with your voice rather then the cheesy intro. I know all of you are trying to be creative but this was a bit over the top and came off more cheesy then professional. Do any of us really want to see this kind of thing on CB or would we rather just get the facts (with a joke or two here and there)and go about our day?

 
 
Posted by marwatk Wednesday, Jun 30, 2010 695 days ago

I'm a little late to the comment party, but I just wanted to say how awesome this was! Good luck Joseph!

-Marcus
Versatile Monkey

 
 
Posted by parrot738 Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

Great job! I thought you were already on the Crackberry staff!. I love my PodTrapper app. I think it runs podcasts better than my iPod.