Photo editing head-to-head with PicMix v PicStory

By DJ Reyes on 3 Aug 2013 07:22 am EDT
12
loading...
28
loading...
40
loading...

When it comes to photo editing or indeed photo filters, BlackBerry 10 has a great tool but sometimes it's nice to mix things up a little. Like collating pictures into frames or adding a bit of graphics here and there. Browsing through BlackBerry World I've come across two apps that aim to do the same thing. Variety is always good but we'll take a look at them in closer detail and see which one comes out on top.

In this head-to-head, we're looking at PicStory and PicMix - available for BlackBerry smartphones. We'll go through the features of each app and then look through the pros and cons.

PicStory for BlackBerry 10

When I first opened up PicStory, it certainly looked promising. You are presented with uploads from other PicStory users, all of which you can rate, comment or flag. Then you see a camera icon at the bottom for you to create your own. With a variety of frames available you can be sure to find one that suits for the style you want. Just pick the frame you want and start adding pictures. Do this by selecting a section and choosing a photo to go in there. Once you have the selected photo, you have a choice of adding some effects and filters too. There's quite a bit to choose from which makes it nice. You can also change the design of the frame itself. There's choice between different colors, patterns and designs depending on the type of picture you want to produce.

PicStory Frames

You can also add some stickers to the photo too. Again, with a nice variety - from butterflies, birds, food and more. Once you are happy with the final design of your PicStory you can then upload it to either Facebook or Twitter, make it your BBM profile pic or just go ahead and post it to your PicStory catalogue.

Apart from frames, you can add graphic designs to your photos instead. There is a nice selection of graphics that come under a kind of theme. Select the theme from the top row and then you are presented with different designs similar to that. There's even a BlackBerry Spark design frame too. Though in the thumbnail selection menu, these do show up quite pixelated but not in the end result, so not a huge deal.

While there isn't an actual option to save the photo to you BlackBerry device, they do seem to save anyway. I was initially annoyed when I couldn't find a way to save the photo but when browsing through my photos I did find ones I created in the Photos folder of the device.

PicStory Menu and Profile

PicStory doesn't stop at just the ability to create photo frames. It's also community-based and you can see what others have uploaded. You can then comment and 'like' the photos too.

One thing that did baffle me about PicStory is that after creating your very first photo, before uploading, you are asked to login with either your Facebook account, Twitter account or your PicStory account, if you have one. If you don't have one, there doesn't seem to be an option for you to create one. Which seems quite odd. So, how do you get an account in the first place to login? As I couldn't find a way to create one, I decided to go ahead and use my Twitter account. Logging in seems to be the only way to save the photos and view them via the app. It is also the only way to comment or like other's photos too. I'd rather not have to use my Facebook or Twitter account to login. I contacted the developer to find out exactly why this is and they responded saying that they phased out creating accounts. Only those who created an account initially have the ability to login in via their account. Any new users will have to login in using either Facebook or Twitter to use the app.

This is a bit of a bummer as I would much prefer an account but it's not huge deal breaker for me personally.

PicMix for BlackBerry 10

Upon loading up PicMix, you can already see similarities to PicStory. You are presented with the most popular photos with further options in the menu or Action Bar. One thing that is very clear is the ability to register or login from the get go. Even before creating your photo. There is no need to use a social media login either.

PicMix does have a a wider variety of frames available, split into different categories. They have your standard frames, where you can insert multiple pictures but also have a wide range of graphic frames, if you want to be even more fancy with your photos, including frames for certain occasions.

PicMix Frames

PicMix also has some extra features like making use of your BlackBerry's accelerometer (on BlackBerry 10), allowing you to shake the device to cycle through different frames. This only works in the Magic Frame category. It's a nice little gimmick, giving PicMix a few little bonus points there. You also have the ability to create your own custom frames, where you select the style and border design. Kind of like mixing and matching to make your own.

Once you have chosen your frame, added your photos. You can add filters, effects and stickers. It has a nice selection of filters to choose from. Adding one to each photo feels a bit tedious though. You have to tap the photo you want to add a filter to, tap the filter icon then select your filter. To filter another photo, you have to tap the filter icon to deselect it, tap the next photo you'd like to add a filter to and then tap the filter icon again to see the filters. It would be so much more efficient to just be able to tap the the different photos even when the filter selection is selected. This is where it loses a few points to PicStory in ease of use.

PicMix Saving and Social Sharing

PicMix comes back though when it comes to saving. It is a lot more obvious. Once you're happy with your frame, you give it a title and have tick boxes available to Save to Photo Library and Post to Public Feeds. Save to Photo Library is ticked already and cannot be deselected, so even if you didn't want to upload to the community, it will be saved. After finishing, if you didn't select to post to social sites, you are prompted again or set it as a BBM profile picture. It would be nice to select where the photo gets saved but knowing it gets saved to the Photos folder on the device is good enough.

One issue I have with PicMix is that the app crashes upon trying to open the My Frames category. It happens both on my Z10 and Q10 so I don't think it's an fault with my device.

So, which ones comes out on top?

They both offer the same thing, of creating frames out of your photos and sharing them to the community and social media sites. However, I'm leaning towards PicMix more - purely for the fact that there are more frames and categories to choose from. It is also a lot more user friendly than PicStory. I also prefer that I don't have to use a social media account to get started.

Both apps are free so you are getting more 'value' with PicMix offering more variety. There are sections that look like they're coming soon. So, we could see a paid version in the future - though it would be great if these features come at no extra cost.

Although this head-to-head is between the BlackBerry 10 versions, both PicStory and PicMix are available for legacy BlackBerry devices too. If it's something you're looking for, check them out now. They are available for the Z10, Q10, Q5 and BlackBerry OS 4.5 and above for PicStory, OS 5.0 for PicMix.

More information / Download PicStory from BlackBerry World
More information / Download PicMix for BlackBerry 10
More information / Download PicMix for legacy BlackBerry

36 comments

HotGroove

First?

Posted via CB10 using my freaking sweet Z10

lengend

You know what we need? Kid Pix. Wooohoooo

Posted via CB10

FastLane228

WTF... is the deal with all those kids on the login, it just doesn't feel right

BBM CHANNEL C000EF854 < bbry stocks*C0004ABC9

FastLane228

I'm sure when you review it you saw that right

BBM CHANNEL C000EF854 < bbry stocks*C0004ABC9

FastLane228

Picstory, doesn't load pictures to even edit Z10

BBM CHANNEL C000EF854 < bbry stocks*C0004ABC9

logistical

Seems ok so far.

Posted via CB10

takeo

PicStory is available on BlackBerry 10 and Legacy too - but there is no link in the article?

Posted via CB10

DJ Reyes

PicStory doesn't have a separate BlackBerry World link for legacy devices. That link should work for legacy devices. Does it not work for you?

Posted via CB10

LoganSix

So, this is like Instagram.

buckdekan

Has anyone found a good z10 app that uses the filter where you turn the picture black and white then you can put in a splash of color? Is there a free app?

DJ Reyes

MagicPhotos does that but it's not free. But I think the price tag is worth it.

Posted via CB10

imcurved

How are these compared to Photo Studio? Thanks.

Post via CB Z10

sirxdaniel

can you add text?

z10er

cantina4me

You can on Pic Shop :) It's a good app.

Posted via CB10

JhonHartQnx

What i really hate about picStory is that u can't remove the logo from your photos unless you use another app to cropp them.. i used picMix, PhotoStudioPro and PicShop

Posted via CB10

samaher123

i wan't inastgram plezzzzzzzzzzzz

Posted via CB10

samaher123

I wan't instagram )':

Posted via CB10

DSL9700

samaher123 everyone one of your comments if looking for instagram. you should sideload it.

bigr3n

Anyone? Is there any mobile app like a photo shop use? I would like to create covers for cd's.

Posted via CB 10 On the Underrated Z10

Joya Blain

I need to test it now
______________________
Your Guides http://www.howtodo247.com

fast666

For photo editing and collating nothing comes close to PicShop. Use it daily for my channel and love all the features.

ChannelX C000D3759 We review channels

DSL9700

Props to indonesian developers for bringing solid apps to blackberry.

simonbhyong

I can't even create an acc 4 myself, so is still Picmix and Instagram 4 me, how to create an acc in Pic Story?

Posted via CB10

DJ Reyes

You can't. I stated in the article that PicStory took this ability away. You have to use a Social Media account.

Posted via CB10

thelastkazekage

Instagram pls! :)

Posted by @thelastkazekage via BlackBerry Z10 smartphone

SapphireEcstasy

Instagram screw the other BS wanna be apps lol

Posted via Q10

kartikeyarathi8

Will be ever grateful to BlackBerry if Instagram n facebook app can be full operative like in case of iOS or Android platforms. Sth worth using BB10!

Posted via CB10

Serkle K

I use PicStory and Photo Studio so far on my Z10. I might give PicMix a try. It would be nice to get a native Instagram App on BB10, but since I've never used it, I don't feel like I'm missing out on too much. With all that said, I also wish BlackBerry would bring Scrapbook to BB10.

Posted via CB10

Muhammad Hamed

Picmix ftw

BlackBerry Z10

cantina4me

I use Pic Shop and Photo Studio Pro. I like both of them a lot but mostly use Pic Shop because I can add text and layer images together.

Posted via CB10

InongInge Adinegara

I try to download... unavailable for device...???? instagram why not also cant

Posted via CB10

Ray Luevano

i can't log in to my account. help please. email not valid... the only mail i have

dini_lilsister

It's cool, I've already try in... But why I can't log in ???!

Uzosecond

so on picmix i can't move from step 2-select photo to step 3-share photo. i don't know how,been trying and selecting all the options on my screen but i'm still stuck in step 2. anyone know how i can deal with this??please its urgent.