Join Our 3 MILLION+ Members Today! Register Here | Login
Login or Register to post comments

23 Comments

Posted by Kevin Michaluk Thursday, Aug 05, 2010 658 days ago

Kevin (aka Ryan Seacrest): Ahh Joe. Your videos are torture for me to watch. I seriously need to get some island life happening in my life. Now let's see what the judges thought of your review!

CrackBerry Idol Judges

Dieter: Hiliarous video! Great to see some specifics in the written review, especially nice pros and cons for each product. It could have used maybe one more round of editing to make each section feel a bit more cohesive, but that's a niggle. Nice job!

Georgia: After watching your first two videos and reviews I was super excited to see this next video and was not disappointed. The video was creative and informational from start to finish. The breaking news in the middle had me laughing out loud (Sorry about your Phone). I believe that people would watch your reviews even if they did not have a BlackBerry. The written review was equally engaging, it was nice that you tested out both products on the field. You're a shoe in for the next round!

Craig: Joe this is an epic video. Very well done, funny, informational, and scenic. Your written review was great too, covering all the important points about each case, backed up with specifications. Excellent work!

 

 
 
Posted by Spiral_ouT Thursday, Aug 05, 2010 658 days ago

Hahaha. No one else could make a accessory review this funny or interesting. Only critique is that you didn't explain what exactly the case mate fuel does. I thought it was just a belt clip case until I saw the lights on it. Good thing your personality and creativity blow the other reviewers out of the water.
Going to be VERY hard to follow up this one guys.

 
 
Posted by Xopher Thursday, Aug 05, 2010 658 days ago

Your video was entertaining and informative. You definitely have a flair for the video reviews.

The written review was well balanced and covered all the in's and out's. Definitely the best review I've seen this round so far!

 
 
Posted by The_Adventist Thursday, Aug 05, 2010 658 days ago

Ok let the hissing and booing at me start now.

If I am wanting a review of an item that's what I want not to watch a comedy. The "review" made me not even want to read the written review.

Aloha means hello and goodbye. I am sorry I won't be able to put a vote your way this time, so I must say aloha Joe.

 
 
Posted by Bold9700Dude Thursday, Aug 05, 2010 658 days ago

I'm completely with you on this one. I can't believe what a circus this site is starting to turn into with characters like this guy. In his last video review he didn't even say what the product did. He seems to reel his fans in with scenery and little to no value in the review itself.

I found that interruption rather disturbing, and it would definitely turn me off of watching reviews on a site featuring ones like this. I'd probably stop following the site altogether.

Here's hoping that people will realize that the CrackBerry idol winner is supposed to be writing articles for this site, and not wooing visitors with scenery and bad jokes.

 
 
Posted by kaerfree Friday, Aug 06, 2010 658 days ago

This was the best video review I've seen on this website. Nothing against anyone else but it was entertaining and I came away knowing more about the product then I did going in which is essentially the whole idea of a product review. And really with a name like case-mate fuel it's pretty self explanatory what it's there for. It never hurts to change things up a bit. Just put your tea party signs down and live a little.

 
 
Posted by The_Adventist Friday, Aug 06, 2010 658 days ago

I am as Canadian as the start of BlackBerry. Made, born and lived here all my life. What you Americans have going on with this tea party thing - I dunno. You'll have to educate me on that.

Not every review is fun and games. Let's see a serious side of Joe. Kevin has fun when fun is due and brings home the serious reviews when needed.

But like I started off with, let the booing and hissing begin because I have a difference of opinion.

 
 
Posted by yenyob Friday, Aug 06, 2010 658 days ago

why does this site have to be stuffy and monotonous with the way video reviews are done? By what some of you wrote, that's what you want. I like to be entertained and it was, well, entertaining! Not that the current crackberry team is boring in any way, but this type of review adds a little more fun. I don't see a review of the Torch or any other major release being done in this manner, but for the everyday apps or accesories...I loved it.

good job!

 
 
Posted by Aloha Joe Friday, Aug 06, 2010 658 days ago

while often used as a salutation...Aloha does not "mean" hello and/or goodbye.

“Alo“ means presence, front or face while “ha“ means breath or to breathe or the breath of life.

So the literal meaning is “In the presence of breath” or “In the face of breath” or “In the presence of the breath of life.”

With that Aloha Joe appreciates your comment, as well as your opinion.

 
 
Posted by mdjones21 Friday, Aug 06, 2010 657 days ago

BAOW!

 
 
Posted by Dragondima Thursday, Aug 05, 2010 658 days ago

The judges and Xopher basically said everything I would have said. So to keep this short. GREAT JOB A+ work! I can't wait to see what you do for us in the next round!

 
 
Posted by pkcable Thursday, Aug 05, 2010 658 days ago

A+ work my friend!

 
 
Posted by Spiral_ouT Friday, Aug 06, 2010 658 days ago

This is Crackberry Idol. This is the time to show your full potential. If Joe can pull a off a review like this, I'm quite certain he could do a serious one as well.

 
 
Posted by Aloha Joe Friday, Aug 06, 2010 658 days ago

...would like to thank EVERYONE (esp. his fellow contestants) for the support as well as the constructive criticism. For those that are hating and not congratulating...that's ok, after all Aloha Joe can't be everyone's "cup of tea"...and...Aloha Joe is ok with that fact. Considering the company surrounding this competition, Aloha Joe is honored and humbled to be amongst these talented individuals. Further, Aloha Joe understands that you may have your favorite(s) and may be voting for "some other Joe". Regardless, Aloha Joe would once again like to thank EVERYONE! Mahalo!

 
 
Posted by Dragondima Friday, Aug 06, 2010 657 days ago

Even though I'm not a tea drinker, I can appreciate what you're saying. Unfortunately these things can become a popularity contest, but I'm certain you have made it this far based on your awesome audition, and even better app review. Personally, I don't understand why people are "hating", but if it makes you feel any better, the people in my close group of circle that follow this really like you! I speak for myself in saying you're doing great! I look forward to seeing you in the next round. You have my vote!!!

 
 
Posted by trjnberry Friday, Aug 06, 2010 658 days ago

For a contest, this video entry was great. It had creativity, personality, exciting scenes, good story line, fun to watch. Nice break from all the drama unfolding about RIM, OS 6, and the Torch. (No Verizon ever? WTF?!?!) I loved the scene of the BB in the hot tub. I liked the scene of the holster dropping the phone easily. Reminded me of my old Env before I went BB. My car door caught that holster just perfect about a dozen times a month and down went the phone on to the street. If it were a BB, it'd be toast. Fortunately, I got a Seido now that holds the phone securely in the holster, so I don't I drop my BB. Loved the Hawaii 5-0 music clip. The scenes of Waikiki Beach and Diamond Head. Very cool.

Now, let's get serious. Let's talk reviews. We the reader want to know is this product worth our hard earned money? Does it do as advertised? We want facts. We want the real story, not the sales pitch. Not the info commercial. We want to know does it do what it says it will do and what does it do exactly?

I felt your video fell short of explaining what these two cases do. OK, so you had a bb in a arm sleave while you sat in a hot tub. I had my BB, wrapped in a grocery plastic bag in pouring down rain at a football game in late December. Protected my BB just fine. So, why do I want to spend $25 for a Aquapac? Ziploc bags have been protecting my BB in wet weather. Why pay $25 for something I can get for a free or close to free?

I liked your written review. Nice and short, good flow, pros and cons were detailed. Good advice on how to test out the water pac, use the speciality pac if you're in humid places, but I would have liked it you could have explained why this was better than a ziploc bag. For the fuel case, I thought you spent a lot of time on the holster malfunction and not much how the case works. Informative stats, but I would have like have seen the phone in action.

Aloha Joe, I hope you are just playing a character in a summer contest. Because if this is the kind of a review we are going to get from you, this common theme of showcasing your venue rather than the product and sounding like a high school jock rather than a professional, I think Crackberry will suffer with you on the team.

 
 
Posted by Radius Friday, Aug 06, 2010 657 days ago

I have a Fuel Case for my 8900 and never had a problem with it. The clip is very strong and there's no way it will dislodge. Perhaps the different form factor of the 9700 is a problem though, I am not sure.

Overall I'm satisfied with it, I can get through a 4 day weekend with juice to spare using it.

 
 
Posted by moyjoy Friday, Aug 06, 2010 657 days ago

LOVED the written review. It's actually one of my favorites on crackberry (no offense to the regulars). ;) The video though... loved some, hated some. So that means it was alright.

I think if the video was posted AFTER the written review or the video was pieced out after each written segment it would have been prefect. But the video was more of a commercial for the written review letting you know what it as going to be about but not actually getting into the details of the products enough.

Still though... as a whole one of my favs!

 
 
Posted by Shoftiel37 Friday, Aug 06, 2010 657 days ago

Great job on the reviews! Especially loved the scenery, was just on Oahu last week for vacation. Love your Islands. looking forward to see you in the next round.

Mahalo!

 
 
Posted by The Consigliere Friday, Aug 06, 2010 657 days ago

Man that was awesome, I liked the reviews AND the scenery, I thought Florida was a nice place to live until I saw all that.

 
 
Posted by _X_ Friday, Aug 06, 2010 657 days ago

Aloha Joe, I've liked you other videos quite a lot, I've found them entertaining and informative.

This video however was neither and probably ranks up there with the worst review in the idol to date.

Here is why.

I honestly did not know what you were reviewing, my first thought it was the water proof armband.

Your scene did not flow, the constant scene shifts just added to the confusion, and pain of watching the video

The review provided no content, I was no wiser about the products you reviewed.

Honestly I think your trying to hard to be entertaining and forgetting that the primary role of a review is to provide users information about the product. People feel duped, it's like going to a comedy show and getting a lecture on Newtonian Physics instead.

On the plus side this is one of your better written reviews.

Cheers and good luck
=X=

 
 
Posted by John.P Friday, Aug 06, 2010 657 days ago

Watched the video, and the "emergency news blurb" in the middle made me want to read to see what happened.

The waterproof case you used in the beginning seems better than the Aquapac, don't think I'd trust the Aquapac with my equipment!

 
 
Posted by lilaberry Friday, Aug 06, 2010 657 days ago

I didn't even care about what was being reviewed but went ahead and read every word and enjoyed the pics and vids...way to go Joe!!