Join Our 3 MILLION+ Members Today! Register Here | Login
Login or Register to post comments

24 Comments

Posted by Kevin Michaluk Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

Kevin (aka Ryan Seacrest): Sweet up David. I was hoping we'd see a little sketch of some sort tied to a review... infotainment as I like to think of it. Now let's see what the judges thought!

CrackBerry Idol Judges

Dieter: Clever intro, dawg, pretty awesome. But both the review and the video after that intro were a little ho-hum. I like a 'just the facts' attitude as much as the next guy, but your own opinion (which looks accurate to me) gets a little lost in the dryness and a little repetition.

Georgia: Liked the small skit at the beginning of the video, great way to get our attention right from the get go. Your voice did get a bit monotonous through the latter part of the video, try to change your tone and pace to keep us engaged. In the written review, you did a great job going over each of the features of the application, Bravo! The review gave me a nice grasp of what I could do with this application and how it differs from using Facebook on the web. I did find your sentence structure could have used a bit of work. Discussing how the application is more suited for the Facebook addict than the novice was a nice addition. That kind of information is why people read individual reviews instead of just reading the iTunes application information. Nice job.

Craig: The video review started off interesting with a clever-ish sketch, but then went downhill quickly. You sounded bored (or tired) and seemed to stumble through the features. I had to force myself to pay attention. Your written review was much better. It covered the apps features. I would have liked to have seen a little bit on what RIM added in this new version. Lastly, BlackBerry has 2 capital B's :-)

 
 
Posted by LaFrance1987 Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

A picture of a BlackBerry displaying a steaming turd would have perhaps been a more useful review, but kudos for attempting to make it look and sound like a useful app.

 
 
Posted by camelontherun Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

anything more timely?

 
 
Posted by that_maynard Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

I didn't know that about changing the status updates, I also do not like knowing about Farmville updates! I learned a lot from it.

 
 
Posted by BBThemes Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

you can also use the follwing shortcuts too

Poke - P
Send a friend request - V

also when in a notification

To view the next notification in the list - N
To view the previous notification in the list - P

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

Nice skit at the beginning. That was probably fun to write, shoot, and edit ... ... ... aaaaaaand then you lost me. While I think your video review was thorough enough, it was too long and rather boring. In fact, I stopped watching 2 minutes in.

I do agree with the conclusions you wrote. This app is slow and lame except for the calendar/contact sync.

Best wishes in the contest!

 
 
Posted by adamcar Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

Stop saying umm all the time, it gets annoying. I wish I had the time to enter this thing!

 
 
Posted by Pointnino Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

Nice job on the review sir. I liked it. The video could have used a few improvements, but I can't speak on that because it's probably 100 times better than anything I would have done. For real. Good info though. I actually learned a few things too.

One addition to the "cons" section that I would add would be the issue I have been battling with ever since I downloaded it back in the day... is the Mobile Uploads (pictures). I can only get about 1 in 20 images to actually load to Facebook without giving me some kind or retarded error. I really don't even try anymore. I just email them to myself and do it from the PC. Only been able to add a caption on my BB... once. That never works. If that worked the way it was supposed to, I'd be 100% stoked about FB for BB. I notice that a lot of people rip it, but I also never used another phone's app to see how they compared either, so as they say; ignorance is bliss I guess. Anbody have any suggestions about the picture problem I have, I'd love to hear them.

I'm running OS 4.5.0.186 on a Sprint 8330m (which may be the problem).

Thanks!

 
 
Posted by frcollier Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 583 days ago

I found the easiest way to upload a photo from my Berry is to email to the unique FaceBook email address, that links directly to your Mobile Photos.Profile>Photos>Create A Photo Album>Mobile Photos Tab, the weird email address there links directly to your acct. I put it in the phone book, so when ever I want to put a picture on Facebook, email to that address. Works better than that app ever has. But still not as good on my Android powered HTC device.

 
 
Posted by Xopher Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

The skit at the beginning was the only thing really good about the video. It went downhill quickly from there.

Newsfeeds was good information. You didn't show what does show for a person's profile when you click on someone. You didn't show image galleries, which is another nice feature of the FB app. You barely touched on the application itself other than scrolling over the icons. That is barely a walk-through.

The other thing that bothered me was the "Um's". You said "Um" 35 times throughout the video. That's an "Um" every 11 seconds. Anytime I hear a reviewer saying a lot of
"Um's", it makes me think they don't know what they are talking about and are just trying to fill space. Partner that with only a half-walk-through and it really makes me think you won't make the cut for round 2.

Here's a tip for people. Go over the app ahead of time. Take notes. Know what you want to present before you hit record! If you're going to demo something with a photo (like tagging photos), know where the image is on your BB ahead of time. I little bit of preparation could have made this review so much better.

 
 
Posted by The_Adventist Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

I didn't like the skit. I don't think skits belong in a review but TMO.

After the skit was over you sounded board with you own review. Like everyone else has said: more life, less ums, know what you are going to say, practice then present.

 
 
Posted by berryaddict47 Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

The one bad thing about the application is that the notifications aren't synced with the facebook web site. On the iPhone application, if you check a notification, it isn't new on the website or the other way around. If you check a notification on your computer, it's still unread on the phone. Besides that the application is great.

 
 
Posted by XWolf Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 583 days ago

For some reason the notifications on the app are dead on my 9700; for example - says someone has sent a message, when I select it it says too big to display... Happens with pretty much all notifications. Also, only being able to add people via email address is poor.

I have it installed just so I remember to check things and to upload photos, however I then have a shortcut to the Notifications screen in m.facebook.com

 
 
Posted by BluCheze Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 583 days ago

The app itself though you got to admit RIM sucks.

 
 
Posted by boudy_145 Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 583 days ago

You can't view or update fan page info which is a big con

 
 
Posted by DieselCityMag Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 583 days ago

The best shortcut that I've found to use in the Facebook app is......(wait for it).... The Delete From Blackberry Option!! This app screwed up my calendar and contacts. I've had to repeatedly add addresses and phone numbers back into my contacts. I thought it was the google sync causing problems, but it turned out to be the contact and calendar sync in facebook. It is nice to see their facebook pic, but it's even better to have info in my phone still (just in case I ever have to use the Blackberry as a phone).

 
 
Posted by Apocrathy Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 583 days ago

3400+ friends is a ton of friends.

 
 
Posted by berryaddictnoza Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 582 days ago

Thanks for the review! I'm new to Facebook and was wondering about the App. You saved me the time and trouble of trying to figure it out.

 
 
Posted by ghostnyc Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 582 days ago

Blackberry's FACEBOOK APP is GARBAGE. Search the forums, read reviews from App world, listen to people who actually use it. It SUCKS.

 
 
Posted by Rossonero Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 582 days ago

um, um, um, um............

 
 
Posted by netposer Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 582 days ago

I've found that the Facebook app hi-jacks your email and doesn't display emails from FB in your inbox but rather in the FB app itself.

If you have another FB account and also get those emails on your BB then they get mixed up inside the FB app.

Here's my situation:
I have a FB account and get emails sent to a gmail account I have on my BB. If I log into gmail on my pc I see the FB emails. If I open the gmail icon on my BB the FB emails are not there. Fine. But they are in the FB app.

I get a copy of every email my daughter gets inside another gmail account. So with FB send her an email the FB app does the same thing and injects her messages into the FB app I'm logged into.

Not sure how to fix this but it seems that any email from FB sent to any email account on my BB get's hi-jacked by the FB app regardless of the logged in FB user.

 
 
Posted by monkfromwes Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 582 days ago

I was very excited this morning after seeing the title, thinking that Facebook had finally released an updated app. But oddly, this "review" is of an app that has been around for quite a while now.

Clearly the developers at Facebook are focused on the iPhone and Droid at the moment, the Blackberry rapidly heading towards extinction.

I find loading pictures quite difficult. Used to be able to do it from the camera (I have a Storm), but that's gone now (unless someone can inform me otherwise).

Still, while I didn't watch the video, this was a helpful review for those new to BB.

 
 
Posted by jfriend33 Wednesday, Jul 07, 2010 582 days ago

I thought the review was pretty good. Lets focus on how much facebook for blackberry sucks.

You can't tag people in status updates like you can on a computer.

The friends list updating is slow? If you have hundreds of friends, it takes an eternity!

No chat feature, I'm not downloading another app to do that.

If someone has tagged someone in a status update, it says "In this photo" instead of correctly having the person tagged.

If someone shares a link on your wall, oh yes, you get a notificaiton of it, but it only displays the persons last post to your wall.

Overall, I feel like facebook for blackberry is like a vintage pager, ok maybe a two way pager, SOME days. Most of the time it will alert your phone some kind of activity is going on with your facebook, but don't get your hopes up that you're going to be able to really know what the notification was for!

The only thing I thought was remotely cool was when the application scans your address book contacts. When logged on to facebook on a computer, if someone has their phone number publicly listed on their profile, and you haven't added them to facebook yet, sometimes you might get a match and can send them a friend request. That part though is still dysfunctional because 75 percent of the results come up as people in foreign countries with phone numbers not even remotely similar to whats saved on your phone!

I'm not going to lie, being able to update my status or send messages from an application is much easier than sending text messages from a dumbphone, but still...things could be drastically improved.

 
 
Posted by DyireL Wednesday, Jul 28, 2010 561 days ago

hi i have a blackberry bold 9000 and a 500mb data plan.
i want to know if i keep my facebook open but im not using it, would it cost me a lot of data? send me an info or answer in my email HDKahel@yahoo.com thank you