Join Our 3 MILLION+ Members Today! Register Here | Login
Login or Register to post comments

24 Comments

Posted by Kevin Michaluk Thursday, Jul 01, 2010 692 days ago

Kevin (aka Ryan Seacrest): Nice review their Gregg. Liked it a lot! Man I wish this app was free, but I guess that's not up to you or me. Let's check in on the judges with their thoughts on your review.

CrackBerry Idol Judges

Dieter: Gotta hit you on the "your/you're" thing, dawg, but other than that you owned this review - well I might have mentioned the fact that you can't post to craigslist earlier, that would be a dealkiller for me. Your video clearly shows you understand the app but doesn't quite help me understand it, it wanders just a little bit and it's hard to keep a sense of place. Still, real potential here, hope you make it to the next round!

Georgia: I enjoyed reading your written review, you had a sweet flow through your sentences. The video meandered around the applications basics but I never really felt I got to know the application enough. I think you did a good job, and I hope that you get to stay in the competition.

Craig: Great blog post. Few grammatical errors as Dieter mentioned. BlackBerry has 2 capital B's. The video was good because you showed the app in action. It allowed me to see it in action. I would have liked to have seen a more professional edit to polish it up.

 
 
Posted by sweetlittlehugs Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

It doesn't allow you to post? Maybe we need the craigs
Pro+ app.

 
 
Posted by XWolf Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

Overall a good review. I was just disappointed that after reading it I had to be told by the app store that it is US only. Really that should be in the review as a con.

 
 
Posted by henry2264 Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

I'm quite sceptical of any app that requires you to pay to browse a free website so I especially not happy with this one. It only works in the US and paying $4.99 is too high price to pay just because your too lazy to type craigslist into your browser and have the ability to choose a font.

I agree with XWolf with this one. The review should of been critical of a app that charges to browse a free website with zero functionality outside of the US. I would only given this app a 2 or 3 out of 10, looks good but overpriced with limited functionality and use.

 
 
Posted by henry2264 Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

I'm quite sceptical of any app that requires you to pay to browse a free website so I especially not happy with this one. It only works in the US and paying $4.99 is too high price to pay just because your too lazy to type craigslist into your browser and have the ability to choose a font.

I agree with XWolf with this one. The review should of been critical of a app that charges to browse a free website with zero functionality outside of the US. I would only given this app a 2 or 3 out of 10, looks good but overpriced with limited functionality and use.

 
 
Posted by henry2264 Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

I'm quite sceptical of any app that requires you to pay to browse a free website so I especially not happy with this one. It only works in the US and paying $4.99 is too high price to pay just because your too lazy to type craigslist into your browser and have the ability to choose a font.

I agree with XWolf with this one. The review should of been critical of a app that charges to browse a free website with zero functionality outside of the US. I would only given this app a 2 or 3 out of 10, looks good but overpriced with limited functionality and use.

 
 
Posted by henry2264 Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

I'm quite sceptical of any app that requires you to pay to browse a free website so I especially not happy with this one. It only works in the US and paying $4.99 is too high price to pay just because your too lazy to type craigslist into your browser and have the ability to choose a font.

I agree with XWolf with this one. The review should of been critical of a app that charges to browse a free website with zero functionality outside of the US. I would only given this app a 2 or 3 out of 10, looks good but overpriced with limited functionality and use.

 
 
Posted by KoLoNjI Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

Isn't it craigslist.ORG ??

 
 
Posted by RRSpikes Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

Yep, but you're redirected when you use Craigslist.com or Craigslist.net

 
 
Posted by lmengerink Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

I always type in craigslist.com and am redirected to craigslist.org. (Just did it on my Storm2 too.) Not a huge deal, but do believe the ".org" is the correct address for the site. A bigger deal (to me) is utilizing your/you're incorrectly. I see enough of that on MB. Shouldn't see it on a post by the site.

 
 
Posted by Xopher Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

The written review was good. I think you hit the points well, although I wouldn't consider any app over 500K to be one with a "small footprint". I know apps are getting larger these days, but those with 128MB or less will be watching how much space gets taken up.

The video wasn't bad. You hit on a lot of the point in your walk-through. Movement of your Storm wasn't distracting and helped by zooming in on the different portions of the screen. You need to watch the Uh's, though. Uh's and Um's make it look like you don't know what your talking about and are just winging it.

 
 
Posted by webmastir Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

stupid to pay for an app that should be free, imo =/

 
 
Posted by GhostGregg Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

Thank you everyone for your comments! I unfortunately was very rushed in the video making process due to a family emergency. I really wanted to put a better polish on my review but I had a deadline and really did not want to have to drop out of the competition. I hope my flair can get me through to the next lvl where I promise to knock some socks off!

 
 
Posted by decypher44 Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

Honestly, what is it with BB apps being so damn pricey? It's embarrasing. This app should be free. Many apps should be free or $0.99.

But for this app, I wouldn't spend 0.50. Dude, Craiglist.....

 
 
Posted by devGOD Friday, Jul 02, 2010 692 days ago

there is no need for an app for craigslist. it works fine with the BB browser.

 
 
Posted by ST1100A Friday, Jul 02, 2010 691 days ago

One of the issues is not being able to flag posts with this app. I asked about that and was told it would be coming in the next update. Since it's been 7 months since they said that, I'm not holding my breath...

 
 
Posted by mike340t Friday, Jul 02, 2010 691 days ago

agree with devGOD .. It loads instantly in browser.. Same goes with many of the useless banking apps that banks put out.. When the browser works just fine and great...

 
 
Posted by f00fyf00fer Friday, Jul 02, 2010 691 days ago

It's a .org, not a .com

 
 
Posted by Bramsy Saturday, Jul 03, 2010 691 days ago

hi guys. u are 100% correct that this should be free.

i just searched and found this app for my DROID and it was indeed free.

http://www.android.com/market/#app=com.mufumbo.craigslist.notification.a...

im not here to rub it in or phone war or any BS like that. but dont you think that crazy dumb?!? feels like craigslist is pulling a fast one on you. sheesh even makes me mad that they are ripping you off. happy berrying!

 
 
Posted by Bramsy Saturday, Jul 03, 2010 691 days ago

PS, good review!

 
 
Posted by mikeo007 Saturday, Jul 03, 2010 691 days ago

Every concern I had was pretty much summed up by other commenters. Like a lot of the reviewers, you are promoting the app more than reviewing it, but your video and review were still fairly informative. You are also a very confident speaker, which really works well for the video reviews. Good luck!

 
 
Posted by arrago Saturday, Jul 03, 2010 691 days ago

abit rough but has ability, he should be given a second chance to show his talents in another round.

over all his reviews seems to flow most of the time, he seems to know somewhat how to follow a review structure and keep his audiance interested.

 
 
Posted by CrackCurve56 Sunday, Jul 04, 2010 690 days ago

This is a waste, at least for me. This website is known for "porn" and companies that "don't honor" their committments. Sorry but another app would have been better to review. Also, be a bit more cheerful. That would help. :)

 
 
Posted by Scarlett Monday, Jul 05, 2010 688 days ago

This certainly opened my eyes about Craigslist. This is one app I won't buy and a site I won't be visiting. As for the review it was a little choppy but understandable considering the circumstances. I commend you for putting family first as it should be.