Join Our 3 MILLION+ Members Today! Register Here | Login
Login or Register to post comments

52 Comments

Posted by Kevin Michaluk Tuesday, Aug 31, 2010 630 days ago

Kevin (aka Ryan Seacrest): Second up in the final round is Kerri, reviewing the Torch from the perspective of a Power Mom! Reading the review, it feels like the Torch met her demands. Now let's see what the judges thought of Kerri's performance.

CrackBerry Idol Judges

Dieter: While reading your written review I found myself thinking this dawg has the goods to be CrackBerry Idol. The intro was engaging and the voice and tone suited CrackBerry. Breaking the review down into several little sections kept the review flowing at a good pace and you really embraced your user profile and covered the needs and benefits of the Torch to a Power Mom. Kudos! Then I watched the video. The video was fine, but I just couldn't help but feel it lacked the crackiness of your written review. I do think with a few more vids under your belt you'll have the complete package. Overall, solid job and effort.

Georgia: Kerri, you wrote about your busy life and how the BlackBerry Torch 9800 made your life easier in the written review but I feel you missed an important opportunity by not fully demonstrating this hectic life in the video. The written review was a detailed version of the video but to have grammatical errors this late in the game is a pity. You explained all of the basic applications of the BlackBerry Torch 9800 and also gave us various applications that are helpful to a mom, good job.

Craig: Kerri this review was 100% spot on! You really did cover everything a busy mom needs on her Torch, plus you punched it up to the next level by covering the apps that you need as a mom. Awesome! Great written review and great video, covering absolutely everything a busy mom needs.

 
 
Posted by abutterflyloves Tuesday, Aug 31, 2010 630 days ago

The real power-woman-mom, does all the kid responsibility, works outside of the house, spends every waking moment, cooking, cleaning, making lunches, travel time, working, travel time after school, meet the teachers, arrange time off of work to be a part of meetings, plays, musicals, drive the kids to music lessons on weekends, scouts, laundry and grocery for the week. You want me to get the torch cause a soccer mom tells me? Please. Keep the soccer mom on the desktop, and remember the smart phones are for the smart power women who have the three kids and do it ALL. Blackberry for soccer moms just MAKE them feel like a real person. After their kids grow up, they are just another shopper.

 
 
Posted by Kerri Neill Tuesday, Aug 31, 2010 630 days ago

I have three children, work outside of the home, cook, clean, older kids make their own lunches since they're in jr high & high school, travel all over Illinois to meet new military spouses, go to all teachers meetings, doctors appts, homework, choir practice, scouts, young women's, homeowners association, welcome committee, neighborhood watch, consultant, grocery shopping as well as laundry and Crackberry Idol. Not to mention working in date night with hubby, family outings, organized local playgroups, and support for the troops as well as picking up and moving my entire household every three to four years in support of my hubby. I'd say I'm a bit more than a glorified soccer mom but everyone is entitled to their opinion. Oh and FYI not a soccer fan, american football is more my forte.

 
 
Posted by Deathcommand Tuesday, Aug 31, 2010 630 days ago

People will always do this. There are a lot of sexist pigs out there that will do this to discourage you.
Chin-up and onward.

Loved your post by the way.
Read all the way through.

I'll watch when I get to a laptop.

 
 
Posted by mechanic_joe Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Ignore the trolls, this is the best Crackberry Idol review I have read so far. Excellent, clear and engaging, from a Mom's perspective (and I can appreciate this, from my wife's busy life) I found it very informative :) Great job

 
 
Posted by zensen Tuesday, Aug 31, 2010 630 days ago

you sound like someone who feels threatened by someone who doesnt use this phone the way you use it nor does a busy mum need to do the same things as you've listed. The article clearly explains the pros of her choice of getting a blackberry torch and for what its worth it seems to do the job for her and what she does as a daily routine.

i think the word soccer mon gets bandied around too much but I have no problem with her choosing a smart phone to keep track of her day, her family, her friendships. I clearly think she has done the smart thing.

The most ridiculous thing you could have said and I'll point it out
Please. Keep the soccer mom on the desktop, and remember the smart phones are for the smart power women who have the three kids and do it ALL.

Get off it.. its as generic as calling someone a soccer mum.
DO IT ALL is laughable imo because thats blatant opinion. Having kids and keeping it organised is commendable and its a great review! doesn't at all relate to me but were all different and thats the keyword. I swear blackberries were not made just for some ridiculous expectation of what you think a busy mum should be doing

if i somehow missed your point, then i guess were both at fault ;)

 
 
Posted by Xopher Tuesday, Aug 31, 2010 630 days ago

I like the review. The written review was very well done. I did think that the video did come across as an informercial at times, as well as sometimes coming across too flat. Other than that, I think it hit a lot of good points, and was good to see how it helps with your hectic schedule. :)

 
 
Posted by NewSel Tuesday, Aug 31, 2010 630 days ago

I just recently bought my Torch, also. Although I'm not nearly as busy as the reviewer, I find my Torch to also be very handy and great to help me keep track of things.The screen, keyboards, all the options are great.

 
 
Posted by TABpilot32 Tuesday, Aug 31, 2010 630 days ago

I had to wait all day to write an objective comment to Dave's entry, this was a much different experience! I saw this CB Idol entry pop up as CrackBerry is my homepage as I opened a new tab on my web browser and figured I'd better stop and take a look. There were a few small grammatical errors, though I do some writing for flying magazines so I know how that goes, it happens to everyone... Anyways, this video and review WOW'ed me, I have to say even though this is only the second entry, you are definitely the leader in the club house by far! I can't get over how awesome this was, from a real practical stand point. Plus good job Kerri for being able to do this while you work around such a busy schedule!!! You have my vote, for now, we will see!

1. Kerri
2. Dave
3. TBD
4. TBD
5. TBD

 
 
Posted by crackryan Tuesday, Aug 31, 2010 630 days ago

I have heard nothing but great things. I use to have the blackberry 8330. Ages old now, I know. Decided to cut back for a while but just graduated and have a job in Congress. I think it would be a great phone for staying in contact with the office!

 
 
Posted by Kerri Neill Tuesday, Aug 31, 2010 630 days ago

That thing is a work horse and only gave me a few issues. The Torch has it's quirks like all BBs do but it is a great phone and is very well suited for business use.

 
 
Posted by JRF_8520 Tuesday, Aug 31, 2010 630 days ago

Now, I'm not a soccer mom, nor do I have a busy schedule, but this review pretty much sums up everything one can do with a Blackberry. Great review! Haven't seen the video, but I loved the written review! Congrats Kerri!

 
 
Posted by omi10468 Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Dont listen to all the haters your review was great. Really got the feeling of you being a mom and how your blackberry helps juggle all the daily tasks that come with family life. You represent the new "smart mom" in todays technological evolving society. The days of the post-its and little tiny pieces of paper taped up everywhere to remind you of things are fading away as more and more people rely on their digital devices to organize their hectic lives.You had a charisma and I found you angle of he review to be on point. Keep doing you You go gurl!!!

 
 
Posted by quillhill Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Thank you for a review from this perspective. I got the Torch on launch day. I am also a mom and I work full time for a weekly newspaper. It's interesting to see another mom using many of the same apps I do to keep my work and family life organized.
I also got a few new ideas, too, which is great. Thanks again for taking the time to write this up because it shows how the Torch can appeal to many demographics, even us mommas. :D

 
 
Posted by PsychoGeek Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Even though this review don't show you demonstrating it in real life situation I can fully understand your point. I'm a crackberry addict and also full time house husband, taking care of my kid since I work from home. I love how you elaborate all the situation with your schedule and daily task since that's what I also do with my BB...Love it... Such a cute daughter you have and she's one lucky girl :)

 
 
Posted by Flipperwi Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Hi, Though not a mom. I do have a cat though. If comments are not effective or don't lean towards improvements they are pointless.

Kerri, you hit on almost everything I have on my BB. You did a great job and covered how a BB can be used effectively for many different activities. Thanks for the effort. You have brought your A game - Good for you. At one point I thought you were nervous with you tone on the video. You have proved that you have a "Do More" attitude to me. This is very important in what I appreciate in the CrackBerry team, this makes you a good fit. I wonder how many people noticed you hit on Lucky 21 for the number of topics? That's service to the readers. Great!

 
 
Posted by 3Dee Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

So, where's the Torch review? The reason everyone is praising this review so much is the same reason it totally missed the mark - the review was a great endorsement of the many pros of having a BB, but had almost nothing to do with the Torch! In almost every comparison I was thinking 'yes, but my BB can do that' and there was hardly any comparison to other models to differentiate the usability/feature. Although Dave Ps review was lacking, at least I felt as though I'd read a review of the Torch. This was a solid and well written article (not really a review) but I'm not sure I learnt much at all about the Torch.

 
 
Posted by TABpilot32 Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

If you are asking if you missed something because you didn't think it was Torch review then, yes, I believe you did, however, it is possible I am lost... The video was very much as you say a general blackberry ability showing, based on a Torch. However, the review went into all of the sub-categories such as: call quality, battery, WiFi Browser (where she actually compared it to an 8330), etc... I think the point of this round of CB Idol was more about reviewing the Torch and how it fits for 5 different types of BB users, not necessarily how the Torch compares to other devices, then all of the reviews would be the same and thus boring. For that reason I think this review was spot on.

 
 
Posted by 3Dee Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

This was supposed to be a device review from the perspective of a power user. I rather suspect (as discussed in the most recent CB podcast) that the 9700 is more suited to the needs of a power user, and that the Torch is possibly the least suited of all the BB lineup (with the exception of the Pearl) and not to draw such a comparison for the potential user was a pretty significant omission in my opinion.

 
 
Posted by kj1978 Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Hi Kerri,

Good job. I liked the way you commented on how you perceived the performence of the Torch worked for you and did not go into the nitty gritty of the phone's technical specs. Well written, well articulated and arranged, very informative.

I've been wondering what a non-techie and non-high flying corporate person thought of the Torch and your review delivered.

P/s: Hat's off to you for managing that schedule of yours. My mom doesn't do half of what you do and she's already got her hands full. You go girl!

 
 
Posted by mooshka360 Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Good over view of how it works, must say i do agree with Dieter tho, you did an AMAZING job on the written part of Torch, and the video was good, but it wasnt up to par with your writing, but i think that will come in time. Keep it up, you have set the bar for the other 3 now.

 
 
Posted by luvmyhubby Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Aw man! That first comment was totally unnecessary! Anyway. Great review. Not specifically on the Torch but Blackberry in general. Nothing wrong with that.
I am a mom. I don't have a "real" job but I'm busy enough. My Bold keeps me organized, connected & entertained.
Yup! I let my daughter watch videos on my Bold. I even have the game Memory for her. Its a crack up to see her use my Bold. She is 8 yrs old. She can find the game, picture folder,and even send text messages to grandma or dad. She knows her way around a Blackberry!
Love the review. Great to see how a busy mom uses her BB. Thanks for the tips and recommended apps!
Thumbs up!

 
 
Posted by dwaynewilliams Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Your review made me want to get a Torch. Your daughter at the end was a good touch in the video.

 
 
Posted by notavailable12345 Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Thanks

 
 
Posted by DarkStar50 Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

for the excellent review. I'm a Tourist on Verizon so the Torch is not an option for me but your review makes me want one. I would love to have more "real estate" on my BB and the physical keyboard. You get the best of both worlds. I like how you relate this feature to keeping your daughter occupied! BB are for everyone.

 
 
Posted by BBThemes Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

while the written part of the review was great, but the video, along with the segmentation and (a few too many) screenshots came across more about what a BB can do, rather than what a torch can do, which if im honest put a bit of a downer on things

 
 
Posted by STR8WESTCOAST Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Who cares if a soccer mom uses the phone. A phone can't make ones life easier. Look at those hands in the pic they belong to a man. If rim start making quality phones that sell themselves they wouldn't have to stoop to gimmicks like this. Guess all of the busy people will run out and buy one. By the way what was the point of the review.

 
 
Posted by Kerri Neill Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Those are my hands in every single picture. Next time I'll make sure to paint my nails so there is no doubt lol.

 
 
Posted by Vajraja Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Great review! I'm a single guy in my 20s so it was nice to see a different perspective on the Torch. May have to recommend this review to my sisters now.

 
 
Posted by millyblick Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Soccer Moms' rocks!! and work harder than any female. Because they simply does it all and makes miracles happen.
From the house to anywhere, they all always busy. I bet they'll do better in business they your average business man... ahahaha

 
 
Posted by Kerri Neill Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

for the comments, both good and bad. I would have loved to show my actual routine but while my husband and I have raised the older two children for the last 10 years, they are my husband's children from his first marriage. Since we could not reach their birth mother, I didn't feel that it was right to post them on the internet without her permission.

 
 
Posted by sookster54 Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Great review, and seems to be much better than the god awful Storm 2 that I've used. You're a modern day mom (mine's old fashioned and I just gave her an Android phone lol she's lost). BTW what the hell is flip flops?

 
 
Posted by Kerri Neill Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Are the thong sandals for your feet.

 
 
Posted by BeRich Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Great article. I really enjoyed reading this because I, too, am a busy mother and wife. I'm constantly on the go running errands for both myself and my husband. My Torch keeps me organized in a quick and efficient way with reminders and speedy messaging so everything gets done on time. The list of apps at the end was great as well. I will say, you're way more brave than I am, I won't let my 1 1/2-year-old touch my new phone.

 
 
Posted by glschwar Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Great job, Kerri -- this was very well done. Great idea to feature the apps that are beneficial to busy moms!

 
 
Posted by AJErvin12 Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Great job Kerri! Most of all, thanks for introducing a "Busy Dad" to OurGroceries. This will help my family so much. Thanks again!

 
 
Posted by sithlrdvad Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Good review from the average mom, gives you two opinions (Since this phone is been reviewed last time by the other contestant. But this review is more in detail.

 
 
Posted by SQ609 Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

I don't care what anyone says but the Torch is way behind the times. The specs don't compare to the Droids and iPhones of today. The Torch is lacking in screen resolution, processor size/speed, software, and hardware. The Torch was a flop and a sign to Rim that if they want to continue to hold onto their market share they better give BlackBerry users something that no other phone already has. There's nothing new or exciting about the Torch. Everything the Torch has other phones already have. But better. Sigh...

 
 
Posted by MamaBee Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

As one busy mama to another, I think you did a fantastic job! I was pretty dead set against a Torch, but after your review I just may consider one when I renew my contract.

I like how you included some ideas for apps from a Mom perspective. (OurGroceries is fantastic!)

It is nice to see other Mamas using a BlackBerry. I always felt a little odd being the only one of my friends. Sure came in handy today when I took my toddler to the doctor's office!

Keep up the good work, both on CB and as a Mama!

 
 
Posted by Timothinho Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

I love it, good job! You have a great chance of winning here.. :)

 
 
Posted by NancyJG Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 630 days ago

Thanks for the great info on how you use the Torch. I'm eager for it to come to T-Mobile! My favorite feature of BB is one that I never see mentioned, AUTOTEXT. I've set mine up so that when I type n with a space, Nancy appears. I've done lots of shortcuts for words I frequently use (itss for it's; weev for we've, ty for thank you, etc.) It can be long, too, and just a simple letter or two transforms into "Thank you so much for your interest in seeing this apartment. I'd like to arrange a meeting. Are you available on" and then I fill in the rest. it's simple!

I've asked sales people in various stores if any other manufacturer has this wonderful feature, but no one seems to know, nor were they aware of it! So BB is certainly the best!

Please T-Mobile, get the Torch soon! My 8230 Curve is on its last leg.

 
 
Posted by trjnberry Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 629 days ago

I loved the flow of your review, broken into sections about the points of interest and lots of pics. Liked your sharing of cool apps to use. You spoke in a friendly, real user tone, and I think you gave any typical mom user out there a real good idea of why this phone would work for them. I appreciated your real user commentary on how the phone works, pointing out flaws but also sharing excitement that a new user has. Not being a mom, and knowing that my supermom would not touch a smartphone even if she got for free, I can't comment on what you did wrong. (My mom is old fashioned. It took a long time to get her off the type-writer and on to a computer. :-D) From the surface, this review was as good as any I have seen out there. If you win, I will look forward to your future reviews. Good Luck, Kerri!

 
 
Posted by Bold_until_Hybrid_Comes Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 629 days ago

Not a large enough crowd of moms here to have that perspective as part of the permanent team. Even to have a "different" percpective theres just not enough people on this site that can relate to someone who uses the blackberry the way she does. An assumption that there is not many yes, but I think a fair one.

 
 
Posted by Kerri Neill Thursday, Sep 02, 2010 629 days ago

that I would give all reviews from a "mom's" perspective? Why would you judge me unfairly because of a profile I was assigned instead of actually judging the writing and video? You've had it out for us females all along and I get it, you don't want a female on the team. Glad to see you are the minority here instead of the majority.

 
 
Posted by npunk42 Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 629 days ago

Besides being an irreplaceable segment in any culture, moms are good metaphors for supervisors, accountants, coaches, and so on.
Good review, and I don't comment on these things very often.

 
 
Posted by FreeMacBookPro Wednesday, Sep 01, 2010 629 days ago

FREE MacBook Pro http://tiny.cc/freemacbookpro1

 
 
Posted by osutuba Friday, Sep 03, 2010 628 days ago

BANNINATE!

 
 
Posted by Yemson Thursday, Sep 02, 2010 629 days ago

This was a first. Good review that delivers what has promissed in the title. This wasn't a "personal taste, I like this, don't like that" review like so many others out there but a honest "this is my experience" kind of review. This I can relate to. Nice work.

 
 
Posted by pattste Friday, Sep 03, 2010 627 days ago

Awesome review, Kerri! You are my CrackBerry Idol. If you don't win, this competition will have failed.

 
 
Posted by SnoopTodd Saturday, Sep 04, 2010 627 days ago

That "CrackBerry.com! Cause that's how I roll, yo!!!", should be the new official tag line.

 
 
Posted by jwsnj3rd Sunday, Sep 05, 2010 626 days ago

great review got my vote

 
 
Posted by redhot95 Wednesday, Sep 08, 2010 623 days ago

I appreciate your review and you sharing your list of 3rd party apps that make your life easier. GO KERRI!