Join Our 3 MILLION+ Members Today! Register Here | Login
Login or Register to post comments

29 Comments

Posted by Kevin Michaluk Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

Kevin (aka Ryan Seacrest): OK folks, this is the final featured accessory review of Round 2 of CrackBerry Idol. The community judging will start soon, and the community will choose who moves on to the final five. But before the voting starts, let's see what the judges thought of Dave's review!

CrackBerry Idol Judges

Dieter: Really good video review, glad to see that you didn't sugarcoat some of the problems there, but showed that some things worked fairly well - A good review should help people make buying decisions and you nailed that. Your written review seemed to be a little disorganized - or maybe just a little ADD. Good details in there, though. Nice job

Georgia: Enjoyed the video review Dave, though it was a bit long at over 8 minutes. Think about editing the video down post production to its main components. Your voice was clear and you spoke at consistent pace. You did good job demonstrating how to set up the device. I would have liked to know how long it took to load the full presentation. The written review was also well done, good job!

Craig: Dave, this was a solid review. I really wish your video was more in focus. You focused on the BlackBerry but never the monitor so we could see the presentation. I know low light is tough but this is the third round now so competition is high. Your written review was great, no complaints. I'm glad you compared it to Impatica's ShowMate which I really like.

 
 
Posted by Donnje Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

This is a great review! Good job Dave!

 
 
Posted by Spiral_ouT Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

You covered everything and did it well. Spoke clearly with very few "um's" and the flow was nice. Written review was well done too. You have my vote into next round.

As for the presenter.. wow. I was expecting it to be much better than that. I wouldn't be caught dead walking into a meeting with that. Would much rather just carry my laptop and 3M Mpro-150.

 
 
Posted by cdf3 Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

I agree. Great review. I was also expecting more from the the presenter. I thought about grabbing one, but after I've seen the bugs fist hand, I'm going to pass on it.

 
 
Posted by Victor878787 Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

Was hoping it would be a better piece of hardward than that. But however sad it makes me to say it, it is pretty much in line with the quality I would expect from RIM :(

 
 
Posted by Pathtek4 Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

Finally Dave!!! I touch my nipples with your reviews!! Woohoo

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

I suppose nipple touching is appropriate as long as you use your BlackBerry in some way.

 
 
Posted by diegonei Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

Hey, this was a great review. Now I don't know who I am gonna vote for!

 
 
Posted by Torchlover Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

It seems all my apps from my Bold will not download to my Torch as they don't work on the new 6 os.
Vlingo support has not gotten back to me yet. But I love the phone. I was able to download Navigator. But nothing else yet. Anyone else have problems?

 
 
Posted by Toronto Girl Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

Dave: Thanks for the thorough review. Your video was a bit unplanned (What should I show you next?)
I have used an impatica showmate for two years. I've never had any of the problems that the presenter has with lag or with pictures appearing or disappearing. I'm guessing that the extra step enables the slides to be converted properly so that they appear as they would on a laptop screen. Another important point is that a showmate is compatible with devices other than the bb. (but not the iphone at my last check). I've had excellent support from impatica as well. New software was required at the time I upgraded to 5.0 OS. The download links were sent to me as I was boarding a plane and all went well upon arrival. I present and demonstrate software right on the bb so unfortunately the BB presenter won't do it for me. I had read about it and I was wondering. Thanks for the info.

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

Toronto Girl: I agree completely about the ShowMate being a more rounded device. Secretly, if you read between the RIM product lines, the Presenter will also work with other Bluetooth devices (although there is no device software for it).
Personally I will stick with the ShowMate solely for the fact that you can display the BlackBerry screen in real time.

 
 
Posted by John.P Thursday, Aug 12, 2010 649 days ago

You've got my vote Dave! Very well constructed video review, I liked that you showed basically from start to finish on a presentation with the device, pointed out some flaws, as well as some areas it did well at. My only negative about the whole thing would've been the focusing issue, but like I said, you've got my vote!

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

Thank you for the comment JohnP. I'm glad you enjoyed the review and I hope it was useful in making or not making a purchase. My dSLR lens was not auto-focusing when I shot the video, so I resorted to using a lesser camera.

 
 
Posted by Zipper Friday, Aug 13, 2010 649 days ago

Hey, great job there, I have been mulling over buying this thing for a while and now you have solidified my decision to not bother, being that it's too unpredictable for my large presentations! I don't want to be weary of freezing etc or slides not displaying properly so it's my good ole Lappy that will still take care of that for me. Too bad because I really hoped this badboy would work well.

Great job sir.

 
 
Posted by antharris88 Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

Don't listen to the judges! This is the only review ever where I have read the whole article! So well done you!

I wish people had better things to do instead of counting um's o well sign of the times.

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

antharris88, thank you for this comment. I'm glad you were able to read all the way through. Judges comments or not, I feel I did my best.

Crack on!

 
 
Posted by ka3yan Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

Dave, that was an outstanding review. I appreciate how in the video, when things didn't go right...you just moved on. That's exactly what I wanted to see. I think you did a great job!!

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

ka3yan, thanks for your kind comment. You saw a true virgin run with that slideshow and the Presenter... I half expected a few things to go wrong. Ha ha ha.

 
 
Posted by Xopher Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

Very nice review. Definitely need to work on not so many Um's as it makes it sound like you aren't sure where to go next. But, very detailed and great on presenting a well-rounded presentation. The only thing missing was listing the Price.

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

Xopher, thank you for your comments. If there were any "um's" during the video it's because that was a true virgin test with the device and that particular slide show. I have used the Presenter and ShowMate many times in the past, but created a special test slideshow for this review. Anyway...

The price is and/or was listed in my original submitted written review and I'm not certain why it was edited out when published. My best guess is that the Presenter is currently offered at different prices around the web.

Crack on!

 
 
Posted by The_Adventist Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

This was great. The unboxing was a Kevin style with the added flick of the unwanted coverings. I laughed during your unboxing (but that's just me)

I was hoping for a good last review and you succeeded. Well done.

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

Ha! Thank you The_Adventist. I'm glad you enjoyed the video review. That's what happens when video shoots happen at 2am, I guess. :)

 
 
Posted by gabead Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

I don't use BB anymore, but thought you did a great job and thought the product was interesting. I can actually imagine how easy that would make someone's job for showing presentations. I also thought it was funny seeing the Crackberry Sticker on the monitor when it wasn't originally there. LOL.

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

gabead, I love the fact that you caught the sticker placement. That frackin' rocks! --- Oh, and thanks for the "great job" comment. May you have a pleasant mobile device experience.

 
 
Posted by Techno-Emigre Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

I was intensly interested in this review and appreciated it was a true first run. I did wonder if your experience would have been better if the slides had completely loaded before you started and how long they took to load. If anyone knows, please share.

You did a supreme review, therefore complicating my life. We have to eliminate FIVE contestants? That seems impossible. I am voting not only by current work but thinking which contestant's style fits with CB culture and really informs me. Great vids are entertaining, but I want intelligent information and honest pros and cons on products geared to every skill level of consumer. Again, excellent work.

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

Thank you Techno-Emigre. Allow me to answer that the next day I went back and allowed this same slideshow to fully load before proceeding ... and it failed again. Conversely, I loaded the same PowerPoint slides into the Impatica ShowMate and different issues came up.

Trust me, the original slides used minimal effects. Bottom line again is if you want to use these devices your slides need to be scaled-down and fully tested before you present them.

Crack on!

 
 
Posted by _X_ Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

Dave great review,
Ignore the judges comments, except for Craig's he was spot on. I'd much rather see a long video covering all of the product feature than 5min of unrelated material.

What I really liked about your review was the detail; in product features and in your benchmark slide. You addressed some of the real world issues you might encounter when using such a product. This was a very informative review. I really enjoyed the video.

Constructive criticism
The boxing, was probably not needed you could have,and did list all of the content in your review, however you kept that part fast and did linger too much there.

What seemed a bit rough in the video, was it felt like your ran through the slides for the first time during the video shot. Personally what I like to see is the reviewer already doing their eval and giving us an already digested review of the product: features and know issues. I don't care to explore the product with the reviewer; it also makes the review feel unpolished.

Again great job,
=X=

 
 
Posted by Dave Peckens Friday, Aug 13, 2010 648 days ago

Thank you _X_, that is some awesomely constructive feedback about the video review. You're correct, that was my first time running those slides through the device. I wanted a virgin run for this review as a precautionary measure, "real world" view of what I've seen happen to other presenters.

I've used both devices in the past and half expected the slides to have issues, but no where near as bad as they did.

Thanks again for your comments.

 
 
Posted by bibeberry Sunday, Aug 15, 2010 647 days ago

i used bb presenter as a pdf viewer and it lagged and was on the background for some days.
didn't do me much harm but just irritating that it's consuming power and my 8520 uses a lot for a day.