|
BlackBerry Curve 8520 Review - First Impressions By Kevin Michaluk | 04 May 2009 11:22 | A CrackBerry.com Hands-On First Look at the BlackBerry Curve 8520... A New "Low End" BlackBerry That Rocks?! Rumors of a new BlackBerry with the codename "Gemini" have been running around the interwebs since early 2009, evolving slightly with every new blog post made about it. After some back and forth on device model number (previously labeled as the 8325 after some initial confusion), the prevailing thought on what has been now named the BlackBerry 8520 is that would it would be a new "low end" EDGE-only addition to the popular Curve line. In other words, the Curve 8520 was not something to get too excited about. However, this changed after seeing the first live shots of the BlackBerry Curve 8520 surface this past week, which showed off a slick looking device with the traditional trackball replaced in favor of an optical one... the "Gemini" was officially now a device we couldn't wait to learn more about. And good news - it didn't take us long to get our CrackBerry-addicted hands on one. So grab a bevvy, sit back, and read on to see plenty of photos, a video and our initial impressions on the newest Curve. * Disclaimer: Like all of our pre-release reviews, please note that this is non-commercially available device which means things could change by the time it comes to market. * Read on For Photos, Video and First Impressions of the BlackBerry Curve 8520 >>
A Note About the Pre-Release Device Review As far as pre-release reviews go, the BlackBerry Curve 8520 in this hands-on feels very much like a production unit. The hardware is well put together and the OS is running smoothly. Edge devices like this are old-hat for RIM so that's no surprise. The BlackBerry Curve 8520 reviewed here is running OS 4.6.1, but we expect (hope) to ultimately see this hit store shelves running OS 5.0 (click here to learn about the improvemens in OS 5.0). With it now being fairly clear that devices running an operating system version older than 4.6 won't be getting an update to 5.0, it makes sense that RIM refresh the 83xx series into the 85xx series, which will get the newer OS. And like the Curve 8300 series, where you have your choice of one big feature (8310 for GPS, 8320 for WiFi, 8330 for CDMA), we expect to see more than just the 8520 be rolled out in the months ahead. Again, think Curve 8510 with GPS, Curve 8520 with WiFi, and Curve 8530 for CDMA carriers (this is unconfirmed... just think of it as logical speculation for now). Many of you reading this will go "No 3G, Fail!" but you need to remember that there is and will be (at least for a little while longer!) a market for EDGE-only devices and RIM needs to have a base model, full QWERTY Edge device in their next-generation styling to fill that need. Thus it seems logical that the 8500 series is simply the replacement to the Curve 8300 series. This also justifies why a base model device will be the first to introduce a cool feature like the optical trackball. The Curve 8300 series lineup has been hugely popular and has a lot of loyal users (Curve is the #1 Selling Smartphone in the USA) and there are likely a lot of existing owners out there who would make the jump up to this device. As for attracting new users to BlackBerry, it has also been suggested by many people that the 8520 is device built with Pay as You Go in mind. We haven't heard much yet in terms of carrier pickup for the 8520 (who's getting it) so whether this 85xx series rolls out to a lot of carriers as a replacement to the 83xx series or becomes a prepaid play by a few select carriers, we're honestly not quite sure at this point. Time will reveal all. A few things are more certain though:
BlackBerry Curve 8520 Overview With its blacked-out look and optical trackball / trackpad thingamabob (I'm sure RIM will coin a term for it like SureScroll or SureTrack or something like that), I personally think the Curve 8520 is HAWT! But as stated above, when it comes to actual hardware specs, the 8520 is outclassed by its older brother the 8900. With the BlackBerry Curve 8520 some of the key points to make note of other than the optical trackball are:
If you follow RIM's quarterly reports or talk to any analysts, you'll know one of the areas of concern around companies that build smartphones is the margin they can get off each device sold. Picking up the Curve 8520, while it has a new look you get a bit of a sense of "recycling" of older (high margin!) parts. The display, battery and camera (minus the flash) appear to be straight off the Curve 8300 series. It's kind of like GM tossing Cavalier door locks onto their H3. But honestly, it's not a bad thing at all as the whole package is tight - the Curve 8520 is a real nice device to hold and play with.
BlackBerry Curve 8520 Video Overview The Curve 8520 makes me think of Johnny Cash (one of my heroes!). He was the Man in Black, and seriously, this is the BlackBerry in Black. That said, I recorded the video below Sunday morning (and after Saturday night had no way to hold my head that didn't hurt) hence the music selection. So take a watch to see the BlackBerry Curve 8520 and its optical trackball in action... I hope you enjoy the show!
BlackBerry Curve 8520 First Impressions Picking up the 8520, you know it's a BlackBerry Curve. Despite the visual changes and addition of the optical track-ball-pad, it maintains that user-friendly feeling and form factor of the Curve 8300s and 8900 in hand. And the whole package works well. I was scared to say goodbye to the trackball, but took to the optical sensor within a few minutes. And though I'm not sure what processor is in there, the OS experience is much improved over the Curve 83xx (if it's the same processor, the additional memory must make a world of difference?!). While I'm more of a fan of high-end specs on gadgets, I could actually see myself leaving my Bold or Curve 8900 or Storm or 9630 at home some days and carrying around the 8520 just to enjoy the experience. It also makes me excited for what we'll see from RIM in terms of their upcoming higher-end devices. If this is the look and feel of their base model device, then I'm thinking we should be wowed by their next generation of high end devices. Form Factor - I personally really like the design approach Research in Motion has taken with the BlackBerry Curve 8520's form factor. On the front, they've extended the LCD protector / covering / shiny stuff (don't know what the actual term for it is but I'm sure you know what I mean) both up towards the top of the device and down over the buttons and right to the keyboard. Subbing out the trackball for optical trackpad, this combined gives the 8520 a more modern and sleek look. Though the Send / End / Menu / Back keys are still clickable, they are combined into one piece (the white lines are slightly ridged up so you always find and hit the right command). The rubber coating on the volume buttons and convenience keys also makes them seem more a part of the device itself. Along with the camera flash, another BlackBerry feature notably missing from the 8520 form factor are charging contacts - I guess there won't be a BlackBerry charging pod for this one. Come to think of it, you probably won't skin this device either since it sort of comes pre-skinned with it's rubberized body (no charging pod, no need for skins... lends well to the theory of this being a prepaid play). All in all, it's a more unified design philosophy which I have a feeling may hold up better to wear and tear than previous BlackBerry smartphone designs.
Optical Trackball - There are a couple of other smartphones on the market that use a similar optical trackpad for navigation, and I'm happy to say that RIM's implementation of it on the Curve 8520 seems to be pretty smooth. You can watch the video above to see it in action. Just like the standard trackball, you can adjust the sensitivity of it under Options > Screen/Keyboard. With the Audible Roll setting on Mute, I was a little tripped out by the lack of noise while navigating. With no tactile/audible response, you're really forced to look at the display to see just how far you've moved. I turned the audible roll onto Click, and from there felt immediately more at home. For navigating the OS and doing things like web browsing, the optical sensor works well. I guess it is an eight-way pad, as I could scroll diagonally while web browsing. And it does "click" down, like a regular trackball, for making selections. So far, the only place where I've found myself having a bit of difficulty with the optical input is playing BrickBreaker. I think the traditional trackball is probably better for quick, accurate motions. Though practice does make perfect. I've heard sweaty fingers and being in bright, bright light can cause issue with this kind of an optical input, but I haven't experienced any issues yet. All in all, so far it's a thumbs up from me. And with no moving parts, it should prove more durable than the traditional trackball. Media Buttons - New to the Curve 8520 are dedicated media player buttons, located at the top of the device. While there's no dedicated lock key on the 8520, holding down the Play / Pause button for two seconds does put the device into standby mode.
Display: The Curve 8520 features a 320 by 240 resolution display. I left all my older BlackBerry devices at home when I came out to Orlando for WES, so unfortunately while writing this don't have an older device to compare to (will follow up next week with direct comparisons). I can say that while the display shows a decent picture and video, it is definitely a step down if you've ever used the Bold, 8900, Storm or 9630. And where you really lose out is in web browsing. 320 pixels just isn't enough these days for those of us who like to browse the web on our smartphones. Other Stuff: Be sure to click the images above to zoom in on the photos (I've left some descriptions beneath) and get a better look. You'll see the keyboard is much like the 8900's (which is kind of like the 8700's) but with a slightly different bottom row. There are actually two notification lights. The battery door doesn't feature a latch, but is sort of gently pried off. It is easy insert and remove microSD cards into the media card slot (also underneath the battery door) and you don't need to remove the battery to access it.
BlackBerry Curve 8520 - Some Closing Thoughts for Now...
I'll be sure to follow up with some more thoughts on the Gemini in the weeks ahead. Until then, be sure to drop your comments, questions and thoughts below or in our new BlackBerry Curve 8520 forum.
Related Links
Filed Under:
Device Reviews
|
1st comment. nice
Very nice device but not impressed with camera or resolution
Edge device
320 by 240 display
256 megabytes of internal memory (same as 8900)
1150mAh battery
2 megapixel camera, no flash
processor: not quite sure actually - more thoughts on that below
Its the same resolution as the 83xx series. I would have thought the resolution would match with the 8900 of 480x360
This device is not for you. This is a low end, low cost, high margin, value conscious device. But it is going to sale like hotcakes. I am betting on a $99 or lower price point ($149 max). This device is like the wii of the smartphone market.
Hardware wise, the wii is old and dated compared to the Xbox 360 and PS3, yet it out sells them both because of the unique experience it brings for consumers and the affordable price point. The wii is also cheap for Nintendo to produce, so they are able to make a healthy profit on each unit sold.
Looks like perfect candidate for a prepaid smartphone.
Yep, I said the same thing...PrePaid BB.
This can also be seen as another entry vehicle into the BlackBerry family for those who don't like the Pearl and its SureType.
Offer this "bargain basement" BlackBerry, and it will sure to snag those who are on the fence about getting one. Not everyone wants the highest resolution screens or fast processors or fancy cameras with flashes. It will do for those who just want their messages and be able to make a phone call. Besides, buyers of this device will probably like it and then want to move up. Get people hooked on the lower end, and hope they stay within the BlackBerry family!
I'd say it's the new 8300. For now I'd say the progression of berries, from lowest end to highest would be: Pearl Flip, Gemini, Curve 8900 and Storm, Tour, Bold.
Yap, the Curve 8900 is still much better, regarding the specs. I absolutely agree with your list, but I think that Onyx will be the highest rank :) Hope it will come soon :)
*caldenni is an author of bestblackberry.com site
dills, i want one
NOT DoCKABLE? whaat
I have never docked my 8830 (or my 8700). I don't think the target market for this device is interested in docking. Not including the charging contacts makes the device more sleek, which does appeal to the target market.
Wait one sec. Kevin how did you get two????? Awesome post as always. I still want the 9630 though lol
I want one now!!! Thats supa sexy!
Amazing. Looks like a nice user-friendly device. Maybe not for the power users but the causal BlackBerry fan
Wonder if it would be possible to mod the 8900 with the Gemini optical trackball. Would be really nice...
yea yea yea keep dreaming, i thought the same thing when i got my 8520.
yea,just waiting for 8920
I was wondering the same thing. That would be wonderful.
Thanks Kevin for the review, and excellent choice of music I must say. I enjoyed this video a lot.
LOL @ the 2 new curves side-by-side too
The Video was Awsome. Kevin, You timed that out nicely. Great Job.
I'm just finding out the hard way that the 8520 doesn't support UMA, which sucks.
Also on all these preproduction models, the led seems to be offset?
Wish my BOLD had that trackball
seconded. maybe a hardware hack in the future
What are the two LEDs used for?
jamierson2k - you're really really cool for having a preproduction 8520.
looks cheap
When I saw the 9630 get its cameo I got all giddy. I assume that is normal behavior for addicts.
wonder how good videos look on this.
I was most impressed by the back covers on all the phones.. I loved the Bold's back "coveroo" I'm really tempted to get one now. It looked like a silver grey/silver back with a titanium finished CB logo. love it!
Im diggin it. Really feelin the all black too. In honor i think i'll dress my Storm in a black outfit 2morrow and also grab up that RIM logo background as well. lol.
BTW: CAN SOMEONE PLEASE GET US AN OS WITH GLOWING ICONS ON THE STORM???
Ok, vent over. Thank you! lol.
Can imagine that One is for BT and the second one for Message alert , No ???
Hmm, I kind of like the idea. If AT&T carries the 8520 as a GoPhone model, I might pick one up just for the heck of it.
TMO USA needs to come out with this BB 8520 as a Prepaid BB.
That would give Boost Mobile and MetroPCS a run for their money!
i stand by the fact that on a blackberry you don't really need 3g. I like this device, a 2megapixel camera is not to bad, if you want a high quality digital camera go buy one? lol.
This will be a great change for people with the 83xx series of blackberries and it looks good and looks like it feels pretty nice too. if it came with both gps and wifi like the 8900 then that would be a bonus but its a great low end blackberry that looks awesome and i'm sure will be very durable and long lasting
Is RIM nuts? 83xx phones are still being sold as new. Owners just purchased 83xx phones and now they arent to upgrade to 5.0 so they can sell 85xx phones?
Nothing like buying a phone that is already out of date when you purchase it!
Way to rip folks off RIM! $#@!#@!#
That's the way of the game bro. And it's still way better than the PC market, where your video card and processor are outdated 4 months after purchase.
im just surprised the os is so stable, when the first videos of the blackberry tour came out the os just kept making the phone reboot.
those pictures remind me of ole palm..
Holy blackberries batman!
I dont think this comes at as a surprise,
a budget blackberry is just what RIM needs, they are able to clear old technology (screens, batteries, etc) to make way for new displays, and RIM can tap into new costumes by hooking them on the crack early.
In this economy a budget blackberry is a good idea.
It's a much better looking device than the previous photos showed, so I take back my words about how it looks ugly, but it still gives little benefit over an 8320. In fact, it almost feels like a downgrade from the 8320 since it has no flash (not that the camera is all that great to begin with).
RIM should really be focusing more on getting production prices down on the 8320, thus allowing it to be sold cheaply for prepaid purposes, while having the design and engineering guys work on a single device to rule them all, like a Curve 8900 with tri-band 3G or a Storm with wifi. Or improve the browser.
very nice.. i would actually consider this phone than the 8320...
Looks like my old q9m and q9c with the single flat button below the screen divided by little rubber nubs....looks a bit cheap no?
i guess it looks a little cheap, but hardware-wise, i consider it an upgrade from the trackballs... much like the old computer mice, to optical or laser mice..
damn that video was awesome just for the music... wish they make a trackpad for the bold and sell it on cnn.cn ...... i would soooo buy it.
where's the flash for the camera??
No flash? No GPS??
Why would I give up my 8330?
NOBODY CARES ABOUT AN EDGE PHONE THAT IS BARELY AN IMPROVEMENT ON THE 8900!
GET WITH THE DAMN PROGRAM!!
The QVGA screen is a turn off for me. Even though its more than enough for texting and email, I'm not going back there, the graphics on QVGA displays are just too crude once you've experienced Half VGA, VGA or Wide VGA.
This review confuses me as it implies that this 85xx Gemini series is not 3G, and that that's okay because the Curve has done gangbuster business, etc., etc. I don't know about you, but my Curve is 3G and I wouldn't have it any other way. It's super fast when in 3G coverage, which is most of the place in LA. Are some Curves non-3G? Would a CDMA Gemini have 3G like the Sprint Curve?
the cdma version of the 83xx isn't actually 3g, its 1X EVDO which is slower than the GSM version of 3g which is what everyone has been commenting on. The CDMA "3g" is actually the same speed or slower than EDGE on GSM.
Cheers