Join Our 3 MILLION+ Members Today! Register Here | Login
Login or Register to post comments

23 Comments

Posted by Adlen Wednesday, Mar 05, 2008 1440 days ago

I love my OEM holster - the 8800 one I got doesn't have a seam as pictured in these ones though.

The 5CB ratings are all correct; I love just being able to slip her onto my belt or if I have to carry her in a blazer pocket (school) I can just insert it and with a flick of the wrist the magnetic support slips into place.

 
 
Posted by freaknyea Wednesday, Mar 05, 2008 1440 days ago

The 8800 case is too bulky. I haven't felt comfortable with another case that is small and protects and! is easily accessed.

 
 
Posted by Anonymous Wednesday, Mar 05, 2008 1440 days ago

I actually purchased my first BlackBerry just 2 days ago, an 8310 curve. Because I needed everything accessory wise, I grabbed this holster they had at the ATT store. My other phone was a treo 650, and because of that I had Rhino holsters for fear of damaging the phone. I was a little leery about this case, as I just wanted to make sure the little guy was well protected. So far I think it is great. The review was right on about the belt clip, the first thing I noticed when clipping it on. It has a nice deep grove to secure your belt and if for some reason that thing breaks a little loose, there are some ridged grips on the edge. most other holsters barely get the edge of the belt, and I always had them pop free when sitting up from either my desk or car.

Being the paranoid person, I am, I would have like to see the holster completely cover the phone. I hate seeing exposed edges of my phone, only because that the most likely point of impact if it is dropped. I didn't know about the magnet turning off my phone, the in holster / out of holster compatibility, or notice the groves, but after reading the review, I see I really got more than just a case for my new blackberry. Overall I am pleased with it and having this is my first positive purchase (aside from the phone of course)it is making my transition from Palm Treo to BlackBerry a pleasant one.

 
 
Posted by Anonymous Wednesday, Mar 05, 2008 1439 days ago

I like the holster so much I'm on my third one. It's the cheap flimsy swivel I don't like. I'm not an engineer, but it's obvious it was poorly designed and could easily be improved.

 
 
Posted by WelshSage Thursday, Mar 06, 2008 1439 days ago

The only problem I have with the case is the BlackBerry logo on the flap. I broke off two days after I had the case. Probably because it was rubbing against my seatbelt as I like to have the case in the horizontal position on my belt. But, the plastic underneath the logo is black, so the case still looks good without the logo.

 
 
Posted by boomerbsg Thursday, Mar 06, 2008 1439 days ago

i had a belt case that i got from walmart for $10, and i liked it, but then suddenly out of the blue everytime i bumped the case (Well twice really) my pearl came out and landed on the floor.. no damage to the phone and BSE saved me from scratches on the screen.

i went right up to my nearest AT&T store (i'm with sprint lol)
and purchased one of these for my pearl. it looks great, fits great. it doesnt put mine in sleep mode.. but it does seem to lock my keypad.. so thats good.

i think every owner should have one of these blackberry cases they are stylish and functional.

 
 
Posted by Anonymous Thursday, Mar 06, 2008 1439 days ago

The clip broke on mine 45 days after I bought it. It fractured right at the pivot bolt. I tried to take it back to T-mobile but they said they only have a 30 day return policy. I would gladly send this back for a warranty replacement, but I cant figure out who manufactured it. I really love the fact that my blackberry goes to sleep when it is tucked in.

 
 
Posted by Anonymous Thursday, Mar 06, 2008 1438 days ago

NIce case put for US full figured crackberry addicts the clasp sticks into your belly. if the swivel was 100 and 180 degress and they have the cover cover the whole tome of the phone it would be the perfect case. I always seem to drop my phone on that unprotected corner

 
 
Posted by Nick_IT_NC Friday, Mar 07, 2008 1438 days ago

I had the oem, and with me getting in and out of my car 30 times a day with all the clients, i broke the plastic clip in a matter of weeks, and then i bought a cheap side holster and broke that, if these were stronger, i would buy another one, but not for a while.

 
 
Posted by Clip Buster Wednesday, Mar 12, 2008 1433 days ago

I have broken four clips in less than a year. Holster gets caught on a chair or car seat, then the non-replaceable clip breaks. Needs a metal clip or a replaceable plastic clip.

 
 
Posted by Mr.Ory Tuesday, May 06, 2008 1377 days ago

i noticed that yes the phone is hard to remove from a belt when in the holster, if you spin it horizontal its much easier to remove from your belt without juggling the device at the same time.

 
 
Posted by justin957 Saturday, Jun 07, 2008 1346 days ago

I broke the clip off during the first week. It's only attached with cheap plastic. This is a great case, but VERY fragile.

 
 
Posted by 8830Chicago Wednesday, Jun 18, 2008 1335 days ago

I am on my second case and love it. The first clip broke off after 6 months, but it was my (dogs) fault. I keep mine in my pocket with the clip on the outside when wearing jeans and the dogs retractable leash got caught underneath when the dog was running and pulled the clip off. It really is very sturdy, just dont put your dogs full force behind it.

 
 
Posted by Anonymous Saturday, Jun 21, 2008 1332 days ago

Case is great, but after a year of in and out of the case the flap has finally had it. They should reinforce the flap. I probably take the phone out of the holster 100 times a day and 1 year of use is all it took to wear it down. What am I going to when flap which is barely hanging on finally breaks? Time to buy a new phone then, or a new case?

 
 
Posted by soarin Monday, Jul 07, 2008 1315 days ago

Just my two cents... the clip on the back of my OEM holster(s) broke within a week (each one)... so I was on my third one when it broke I gave up. I now also use a skin... and found that believe it or not the OEM leather holster for the 8703 works WONDERFUL with a Curve with a skin on it!!! Brilliant!! It looks good, protects it, and is really solid feeling... it was a great suggestion by someone at a new store at my local mall..

 
 
Posted by Charlie Sheen Wednesday, Sep 03, 2008 1258 days ago

I was searching for my third case this year, as this one's belt clip broke yet again in a couple of months. I am not hard on these holsters at all. This last time I was standing in our assembly area and the case made a pop sound and fell to the floor.
As I read all these reviews about the poor design of this clip, I ask myself, how many hundreds of thousands of dollars has this company made on this piece of junk?

The clip is obviously a manufacturers defect and should be covered by law in most states for a year.
But who is going to pursue a $20 loss?

I will pay more for quality, and found another case to try.
Not a blackberry product.
Has a longer warranty.

My recommendation is to avoid this product and pay a little more.

Perhaps the Smartphone Experts TopPouch?

 
 
Posted by av8rgeek Thursday, Sep 04, 2008 1257 days ago

I am on my 3rd case since in 3 months. The first holster was a non-Blackberry-branded model that resembled the belt clips for Nextel i560's. I broke it within a couple weeks.

I bought this case and love it, but, again, it broke in a matter of 2-2.5 months because of a seatbelt. The clip is not very sturdy on these. In fact, I think it is the same swivel clip that Nextel uses on their iden phones (i5xx series). I had an i560 from a previous employer and went through 2-3 holsters/year because of the cheapness of the clip.

buyer beware.

 
 
Posted by Anonymous Sunday, Oct 05, 2008 1226 days ago

This holder is great, if you have a belt it fits on. Those of us in the military, police, etc, are forced to carry Blackberries yet none of the holders fit our 2" wide uniform belts. With the nylon riggers belts the military uses, the tight spring clip still slides right off too easily. It seems like a large pool of likely buyers is being ignored.

 
 
Posted by Anonymous Friday, Dec 12, 2008 1157 days ago

I've had the belt clip crack on two of these one within 2 days of buying my curve. Both sheared off were the clip attaches to the ratcheting part. I may be rough or have crappy luck but for now I'm going to be trying something else for a while.

 
 
Posted by Tilghman Thursday, Jan 29, 2009 1109 days ago

The clip on mine lasted less than a week before shearing off at the pin, thus converting an excellent case into a useless piece of clutter. I suppose that I could return it under the warranty, but I've been that route before with other badly-designed devices. I'll look for something that suits my needs or simply make my own.

 
 
Posted by richardshayes Wednesday, Apr 08, 2009 1041 days ago

Just got a new storm pouch from blackberry and whilst in
Paris my hotel room key failed then the metro tickets - wierd

I was wearing a puffer jacket.

Then my credit card gave up the ghost as 'invalid'

I literally nearly took the jacket apart until I realised everything was hanging near the edge of the new pouch.

A few swipes of the hotel room key over the closed pouch and et voila the room key mag stripe was corrupted.

So here I am in Paris, with no credit card and a room key that I can fix.

Thanks RIM, for all the engineering of the BB which I think is great I am now stranded in Paris.

You will be hearing from my lawyers

 
 
Posted by jabohn Monday, Jun 29, 2009 959 days ago

Case is only as good as the clip and the clip is terrible in design. I only had mine for a few weeks and it broke... all I did was get into my car and it popped off. My brother went through 3 of them for his BB before giving up so I'm not going to bother and just get a different brand.

 
 
Posted by jem777 Tuesday, Jul 06, 2010 587 days ago

I had mine with a hard case. Just want the phone to stay with me for a long time.
http://www.artisiancd.com/